Appraisers today have a very strong incentive to come in at close to sales price...it's called prison and plenty of appraisers in most major markets headed there in the not to distance past. Some submarkets...like Memphis...are fairly small and, while these transactions are supposedly at arms length, the reality is that everyone knows one another. So appraisals have gone from end of the spectrum to the other.
If you're doing any kind of rental investing with borrowed money, the appraisal doesn't really mean much. What you want to get to is net returns.....what is the net annual rent. When you get to a deal, hire your own inspector that YOU find to inspect the property...just as a check to find anything lurking beneath the surface. If you're doing turn-key....as you will read all over BP - that means a lot of different things to different people. The one thing it means to most all....is LONG TERM. This isn't something with liquidity that you can get in and out of easily....except at a LOSS. But you're priced out of your current market and that is the appeal to turn-keys. You're saving a ton every month....but what if the economy crashes and you lose your job? You have to think about worst case...stay positive but just know the risks.
You've never owned a home and while they turn-keys are saying "sure...I will give you a discount"....they should really be saying "let's do ONE deal and see how it goes" then you can think about more based on experience. This is really the advice that any of us should be giving you....along with @Larry Fried suggested. There are quite a few options for the smaller investor. If you are hell bent on turnkey, find an operator who has in-house management...there's one from memphis that regularly posts here...check them out. Find one that offers some sort of rental guaranty...otherwise, they will churn you because that's how they make money!! It's the management that will kill you not just what you paid for the property.
Memphis has Fedex but there are some really rough spots there and it's nationally ranked as a killing field....as is Atlanta. Look to some other spots in the midwest...look for a college town where that single family can rent or convert to shared housing for better returns with the management. I hear a lot of good things about Indy...almost anywhere in the states is going to be cheaper than where you are. I don't like it there....but there are a couple of good operators in Columbus and Cleveland Ohio.......take your time with it my friend....but if you do anything....just do ONE and play that out first. When the market crashes and it will.....you can then march in and buy 2 or more for what you'd pay for 1 now....happy to help any way that I can!