I've been in the metro atlanta market as a contractor and investor for almost 25 years now. Like any place else, it depends where your properties are, who is in them and who is managing them. Dekalb county is way too tenant friendly and I'd avoid it at all cost for single family rentals. South Dekalb has become a shooting gallery...parts of south fulton are the same. We're a large city so with patience you can find good renters still but buy by the school districts....at least for what you are doing...for my model, shared housing...it's entirely different and I don't worry about schools or resale or comps...just net cashflow. Find the cheapest house in the best school districts. To buy and hold anywhere for single fam rentals, just stick with the best schools. Our golden arch runs from west edge of duluth to the the west edge of east cobb. You'll do better with cash...just like you would anywhere else. It's a challenge and one I woudn't do without boots on the ground but we're starting to go back into Clayton County. Wouldn't work for you as the schools are yuck....but it works well for shared housing. Same with East Point. The location is great for workers, the airport is expanding & upgrading, we just got the new Porche center down there and Solis is building a new upscale Ritz Carlton type hotel there....all positives.
You'll have to hunt for them but find something that needs lipstick..(paint & carpet) but you can find decent rentals in your range in east cobb, parts of west cobb, cherokee county and edges of alpharetta and johns creek or duluth. Just stick to the better schools and you'll be fine...even when it crashes. Key is find a decent management group which is pretty hard to do...many churn tenants to get first months rent or they offer a lower monthly fee and kill you on repairs and maintenace.
In my mind there is a correction coming and it will be sizeable but it will hit most markets this time. Even so, Atlanta still has a bunch of new construction and alot of apartments going up. Even with a correction, rents will normally go up and, if you're in a good school district, you will keep cashflowing with good management. You will just be upside down on paper for a bit. We have a ton of corporate relocations (mercedes, rubbermaid), great infrastructure, decent transportation and a business friendly govenment all adding to our growth. Just bear in mind that the hedge funds went in deep here and time will show that it was not the best move. You're seeing the consolidation starting here now,,,some are combining forces while others are forming derivatives as fast as they can to get out before the music stops. Eventually the bulk of this product will get dumped on the market and it will kill single fam values here for a bit. If you're in it for the long term, it won't phase you. Go a little lighter on the credit requirements and tighter on length of employments and references to find your best long term renters here.
I love atlanta but I'd also look at Greenville, Greensboro, Charlotte, Nashville, Austin and San Antonio. Texas may be tied to oil....but it's really not.....it has 5 or 6 of the top growth cities in the country. I'm not sure of the price points in those areas others here can speak to that. There are deals anywhere....you just have to know how to find and work them. Happy Investing!