Hi Everyone,
I am a new wholesaler (started about 6 months ago) in Central Massachusetts. I had someone call on one of my online advertisements (for the sake of this forum: Joe Smith). The gentleman has a property in a very small town in Western MA (about 1 hour 20 minutes away from me). According to him, he was fixing this house up to move into himself, but very recently got an extremely well paying job out west making roughly 250k a year. He had bought the house from a big-name wholesaler based out of Texas (for the sake of this forum: ABC Properties) for about 35K in 2012. ABC Properties had purchased the home about 45 days earlier for 20K or so and flipped it to Joe Smith.
Joe, who I get the impression does not have a strong grasp on financing, signed up for investor financing through ABC Properties (hard money, short-term type financing from the sounds of it. Supposedly he has been paying about 20+ percent interest for the entire 3 or so years that he has owned it. He says he only has about $2,500 left on the loan). The weird part is that ABC Properties is actually the one listed on the deed when I looked it up at the registry. Supposedly Joe Smith has an agreement with the lender that once the loan is paid off in full, ABC Properties will sign the deed over to him (Joe gave written permission to the lender to release information to me so that I can confirm this setup and find out the process for purchasing the property; I have left a message with the lender and am waiting to hear back).
Joe Smith told me that he has about 2 weeks before he has to leave for his new job, and wants to dump the property for 50K. I took a quick look at the MLS and determined that the majority of similar houses in the same town had sold for about 100K, so I took a trip to the house last Wednesday to take a look at it for myself.
Bottom line, the house is about 850 square feet and needs some work. It had a steep dirt driveway that I could not even get up with my truck (I was not in 4-wheel drive and had no traction. Also the drive likely would not have seemed so steep had it been paved). I took lots of pictures of the property, and from what the gentleman told me, he's done some work to the house. The work included roof replacement, fully insulating the house, fixing the drywall, digging drainage ditches to relieve the hydraulic pressure on the foundation, and jacking up the house to rebuild the foundation. The roof looked to be in very good shape and the insulation in the attic seemed to look great. However, when he jacked up the foundation, a great deal of the drywall had cracked. The foundation work involved building an entirely new block foundation along the inside of the original foundation. The new block foundation was secured with re-bar and cement through the center of the blocks and a new 2X6 frame was built on top of it to support the house. I am no expert but it looked very solid to me (though no idea if it meets code). So I asked him, "did you pull permits for all this work?" He told me yes.
I told him I had to crunch some numbers and would get back to him in a couple of days. When I left the property I made a stop over at the very small, very friendly town hall, and asked a bunch of questions. Long story short here is what I found out while I was there:
1. There is roughly a $6,500 tax lien on the property.
2. The septic failed Title V in 2012 prior to Joe's purchase.
3. There are quite a few (very small = 2 foot tall) pine trees all planted on the leech field in the front yard.
4. Joe had pulled permits for the roof, and insulation/drywall but has not had an inspection done.
5. There was never a permit pulled for the foundation work that was done.
Upon further analyzation of the property and the comparables, I determined that the ARV was closer to $81,000, the rehab costs came to about $62,000 (very rough estimate), and similar properties have been appreciating at about 3% a year since 2012. I've decided to place an offer for around $11,000 and subject to Joe pulling the proper permits and having the proper inspections completed by the town building inspector (and of course another couple escape clauses). I figure the property sold twice in 2012 for more than $11,000 and was in worse shape at the time. Plus it should be able to sell for more as raw land if all else fails. I figure if he really wants to get rid of the property then there is a possibility he may accept the offer. I have not placed the offer yet, but where values in this small town are not very high, I don't think it would be worth my while to close on the property myself but rather assign the deal to a rehabber. My goal is to make about 8K were this deal to go through.
The problem now, is that time is running out. There is probably just under a week before Joe starts his new job. So I don't think there is enough time to hear back about the buying process from the lender, get an accepted offer, and assign the deal in that amount of time. Chances are this deal won't go through, but I am determined to learn from it. So here's my questions:
A. Let's say Joe moves before I can do anything with the property. Is a long distance closing possible? How would a long distance closing work?
B. Am I missing anything vital here? I have been trying to check everything and verify everything as I go which is why I haven't made the offer yet (this would be my first deal so I'm still a little nervous).
When everything has been verified, I plan to call up Joe and basically say, "Hi Joe. I have an offer plugged into my email and I am ready to send it over to you, but unfortunately it is a lot lower than what you were hoping to get for the property... I mean a lot lower... I was debating whether to even send it over to you or not because I don't want you to be insulted or laugh at me. Unfortunately when I looked at the numbers it was the only offer that would make the deal work for me." Then I'd go on to explain everything that affected my offer price (i.e. failed septic, none of the work inspected, estimated rehab cost, steep dirt driveway, distance from home, etc.) and I'll give him the choice of whether or not he wants me to send it over. I won't tell him how much my offer is over the phone, but will send it over if he wants. I don't think anyone in their right mind would not want to see what the offer is, even if it is low, but you never know. Any thoughts?
Thanks everyone!!! Much appreciated!!!
Mike