Hi @Shawn Patel, I agree you definitely need more work space in the kitchen. It's wild that there are kitchens out there with two little counter tops and nothing else for people to make food on. Option 1 might be your best bet. I would just get rid of the pantry entirely and utilize that space for the fridge and more cabinets and counter tops. You can add in base and hanging cabinets on that wall to make up for taking out the pantry. If they really need more space, the tenants can also bring something in for the corner where the fridge was for more storage. I don't think you need to add another working space over there.
Another option, depending on how much demo/rehab you want to put into this, is to knock down the wall separating the kitchen from the dining/living space (if it's not load bearing) along with taking out the pantry. That would open it up and then allow you to add the fridge and cabinets on the one wall and an island/breakfast bar in the middle.
Good luck with everything! Keep us updated with what you end up doing!