Skip to content
×
PRO
Pro Members Get Full Access!
Get off the sidelines and take action in real estate investing with BiggerPockets Pro. Our comprehensive suite of tools and resources minimize mistakes, support informed decisions, and propel you to success.
Advanced networking features
Market and Deal Finder tools
Property analysis calculators
Landlord Command Center
$0
TODAY
$69.00/month when billed monthly.
$32.50/month when billed annually.
7 day free trial. Cancel anytime
Already a Pro Member? Sign in here
Pick markets, find deals, analyze and manage properties. Try BiggerPockets PRO.
x
All Forum Categories
All Forum Categories
Followed Discussions
Followed Categories
Followed People
Followed Locations
Market News & Data
General Info
Real Estate Strategies
Landlording & Rental Properties
Real Estate Professionals
Financial, Tax, & Legal
Real Estate Classifieds
Reviews & Feedback

All Forum Posts by: Mitch Messer

Mitch Messer has started 73 posts and replied 2076 times.

Post: Has anyone heard of or used Finance Holding Company?

Mitch MesserPosted
  • Rental Property Investor
  • Playa del Carmen, México
  • Posts 2,221
  • Votes 1,767
Quote from @Mark Prather:

I continue to get emails from Steve Mayer of Finance holding Company, but he keeps wanting me to pay a deposit + his 2% origination fee upfront...seems like a scam and wanted to see if anyone has done business with them in the past


I don't know Steve Mayer of Finance holding Company.

I do know that no lender should be asking you for an origination fee until they ... actually originate a loan!

I would ignore/block those emails, if I were you.

Post: 1st BRRRR - a good deal?

Mitch MesserPosted
  • Rental Property Investor
  • Playa del Carmen, México
  • Posts 2,221
  • Votes 1,767
Quote from @Craig Hansen:

I am looking at investing in my first BRRRR. My question is on monthly cash flow. Here are the numbers:

Purchase - $70K

Rehab  - $50K

ARV - $180K

Cash out refinance - will get 100% of my investment back or pocket up to $15K

Problem - I am estimating that my monthly cash flow will be about $100 a month. My other properties cash flow +$500 a month. I am worried about the low monthly cash flow, but understand this will grow over the years. 

Is this a good deal? What are others doing about cash flow on BRRRRs


Getting just $100/mo would definitely concern me!

Come even the slightest ripple (an increase in property insurance, an unexpected repair, etc.) and suddenly you're drowning in a sea of negative cash flow.

Also, are you including both professional property management and vacancy in your operating expenses?

Many first-timers don't, and then they are CRUSHED when reality bites down hard.

Trust me: I was one of them...

Be very careful!

Post: CPAs Recommendations for New Investor?

Mitch MesserPosted
  • Rental Property Investor
  • Playa del Carmen, México
  • Posts 2,221
  • Votes 1,767
Quote from @Mary Ainsworth:

Hello! 

I'm looking for a CPA and/or tax strategist that can help me start tax planning now that I own a property. I want to know what things I should plan to write off, what tax loopholes I can take advantage of, if I should do bonus depreciation - things like that 

If anyone has any recommendations for NEW investors that would be great! I'm looking for people who work with rookies because I'm still new - I don't need the really expensive CPA who does intricate tax strategies yet. 

Thank you! I'm in California and invest in Oklahoma 


Hey Mary, I've got a great CPA recommendation for you. I'll reach out with contact info.

Where in Oklahoma do you currently invest?

I'm active in Tulsa and have contacts working Oklahoma City.

Post: Financing a project

Mitch MesserPosted
  • Rental Property Investor
  • Playa del Carmen, México
  • Posts 2,221
  • Votes 1,767
Quote from @Hugo Lo:

Hello,  I would like to know how I can connect with a financial investor to partner up on a project.  I live in the Greater Toronto Area.


Hey Hugo, while your request isn't unreasonable, you're not helping yourself at all here:

1. Investors work with real people. Your BP profile photo doesn't show a real person. Strike one!

2. Your BP profile is completely blank. Strike two!

3. You've contributed all of three posts to this community. Strike three, you're out!

If you truly want to be taken seriously in this business, you're going to have to put in a bit more effort.

(This is probably the only honest and serious response you'll get to this post.)  

Post: How to wholesale rental properties?

Mitch MesserPosted
  • Rental Property Investor
  • Playa del Carmen, México
  • Posts 2,221
  • Votes 1,767
Quote from @Jacob Lileev:
Quote from @Mitch Messer:
Quote from @Jacob Lileev:
Quote from @Mitch Messer:

Hey @Jacob Lileev!

The MAO formula (70% of ARV Minus Repairs Minus Wholesale_Fee) only makes sense for fix-and-flip deals.

For rental deals, you'll need to calculate the metrics that matter to a landlord, starting with Cash Flow and Cash-on-Cash-return.

To do this you'll need to estimate Income and Operating Expenses to get Net Operating Income (NOI). From there you'll need to determine Debt Service (if it's a financed deal) and Capital Expenses, to then calculate Cash Flow.

The Cash-on-Cash Return (CoCR) will just be Cash Flow divided by the All-In Investment (Purchase Price + Renovations + Closing Costs + Wholesale Fee).

If you're wholesaling these deals, I recommend you aim to offer your buyers a Cash Flow of no less than $250/mo and a CoCR of 10% or higher.


 Hey Mitch!
Thank you very much for that answer I will look into all of this further.
In your opinion should I first line cash buyers for deals like that to understand if they use any finance at all or buy with cash?


As a wholesaler, you're going to want to deal primarily with cash buyers for TWO important reasons:

1. You want to able to (double-)close quickly.

2. You don't want to be unable to complete a transaction because the investor-buyer wasn't able to secure financing.

Oh, I see!
So I'll go out there and find some cash buyer looking for rental :)
Thank you, Mitch, you helped me a lot and taught me a few new things in the real estate business!

My pleasure!

One last thing: I *think* I've found you on LinkedIn, but I'm not 100% certain without a matching photo. I'd strongly encourage you to make it easy to be found and cross-referenced across the social media platforms you use. BiggerPockets is great for real estate networking, but you're missing out if you don't leverage the sheer size of platforms like LinkedIn to start building business credibility. Your future self will thank you!

Post: How to wholesale rental properties?

Mitch MesserPosted
  • Rental Property Investor
  • Playa del Carmen, México
  • Posts 2,221
  • Votes 1,767
Quote from @Jacob Lileev:
Quote from @Mitch Messer:

Hey @Jacob Lileev!

The MAO formula (70% of ARV Minus Repairs Minus Wholesale_Fee) only makes sense for fix-and-flip deals.

For rental deals, you'll need to calculate the metrics that matter to a landlord, starting with Cash Flow and Cash-on-Cash-return.

To do this you'll need to estimate Income and Operating Expenses to get Net Operating Income (NOI). From there you'll need to determine Debt Service (if it's a financed deal) and Capital Expenses, to then calculate Cash Flow.

The Cash-on-Cash Return (CoCR) will just be Cash Flow divided by the All-In Investment (Purchase Price + Renovations + Closing Costs + Wholesale Fee).

If you're wholesaling these deals, I recommend you aim to offer your buyers a Cash Flow of no less than $250/mo and a CoCR of 10% or higher.


 Hey Mitch!
Thank you very much for that answer I will look into all of this further.
In your opinion should I first line cash buyers for deals like that to understand if they use any finance at all or buy with cash?


As a wholesaler, you're going to want to deal primarily with cash buyers for TWO important reasons:

1. You want to able to (double-)close quickly.

2. You don't want to be unable to complete a transaction because the investor-buyer wasn't able to secure financing.

Post: Need HML in AZ

Mitch MesserPosted
  • Rental Property Investor
  • Playa del Carmen, México
  • Posts 2,221
  • Votes 1,767

@Jeremy Holden Are you looking exclusively for hard money, or would private funds work?

How much is being requested? How much renovation is needed?

Post: How to wholesale rental properties?

Mitch MesserPosted
  • Rental Property Investor
  • Playa del Carmen, México
  • Posts 2,221
  • Votes 1,767

Hey @Jacob Lileev!

The MAO formula (70% of ARV Minus Repairs Minus Wholesale_Fee) only makes sense for fix-and-flip deals.

For rental deals, you'll need to calculate the metrics that matter to a landlord, starting with Cash Flow and Cash-on-Cash-return.

To do this you'll need to estimate Income and Operating Expenses to get Net Operating Income (NOI). From there you'll need to determine Debt Service (if it's a financed deal) and Capital Expenses, to then calculate Cash Flow.

The Cash-on-Cash Return (CoCR) will just be Cash Flow divided by the All-In Investment (Purchase Price + Renovations + Closing Costs + Wholesale Fee).

If you're wholesaling these deals, I recommend you aim to offer your buyers a Cash Flow of no less than $250/mo and a CoCR of 10% or higher.

Post: Hello from the Midwest(Tulsa/Broken Arrow) and getting deeper into real estate.

Mitch MesserPosted
  • Rental Property Investor
  • Playa del Carmen, México
  • Posts 2,221
  • Votes 1,767

Hey @Derrick Sanford, welcome to BiggerPockets!

I've been active in the Tulsa market since 2021, when I lived there for a year and a half as a digital nomad under the Tulsa Remote program.

What's been your biggest obstacle to getting started?

Post: 18 Year Old First Time Wholesaler: I Have A Contract But Can't Sell, What To Do?

Mitch MesserPosted
  • Rental Property Investor
  • Playa del Carmen, México
  • Posts 2,221
  • Votes 1,767

Hey @Kris Patel, welcome to the wonderful world of wholesaling!

You're in this at waaay too high a purchase price! That's why it's not selling.

In most markets, your Maximum Allowable Offer (MAO) to a seller should be no more than:

MAO = (70% * ARV) - Repairs - Wholesale_Fee

MAO = (0.7 * 290K) - 40K - Wholesale_Fee

MAO = 203K - 40K - Wholesale_Fee

MAO = 163K - Wholesale_Fee

               - OR -

MAO + Wholesale_Fee = 163K

So, you'd need to get this under contract with the seller at under $163K to make any money at all as a wholesaler.

At $200K you're NEVER going to get any interest from experienced rehabbers.

This is also why you probably got no resistance or pushback from the seller. No one else was likely offering them anywhere near your $175K.

This is why.

You need to buy at a deeper discount.