Skip to content
×
PRO
Pro Members Get Full Access!
Get off the sidelines and take action in real estate investing with BiggerPockets Pro. Our comprehensive suite of tools and resources minimize mistakes, support informed decisions, and propel you to success.
Advanced networking features
Market and Deal Finder tools
Property analysis calculators
Landlord Command Center
$0
TODAY
$69.00/month when billed monthly.
$32.50/month when billed annually.
7 day free trial. Cancel anytime
Already a Pro Member? Sign in here
Pick markets, find deals, analyze and manage properties. Try BiggerPockets PRO.
x
All Forum Categories
All Forum Categories
Followed Discussions
Followed Categories
Followed People
Followed Locations
Market News & Data
General Info
Real Estate Strategies
Landlording & Rental Properties
Real Estate Professionals
Financial, Tax, & Legal
Real Estate Classifieds
Reviews & Feedback

All Forum Posts by: Joseph Bramante

Joseph Bramante has started 11 posts and replied 152 times.

Post: What is stopping you from investing in multifamily?

Joseph BramantePosted
  • Developer
  • Houston, TX
  • Posts 157
  • Votes 132
Originally posted by @Michael Evans:
Originally posted by @Joseph Bramante:

Hey @Joseph Bramante, 

I appreciate the advice. I'll look into those forums for Single Family and see what value I can extract. As for crowdfunding syndications, are commercial lenders okay with having the down payment come from a syndication? 

Best,

Mike

 Honestly, i have never done the crowdfunding thing so I am not qualified to answer. I don't think they would know you are crowdfunding the deal since the "crowdfunding" should show up as an entity on you membership. Again, never done it before so maybe ask the crowdfunding site.

Post: What is stopping you from investing in multifamily?

Joseph BramantePosted
  • Developer
  • Houston, TX
  • Posts 157
  • Votes 132
Originally posted by @Troy Whitney:

Joseph, either you are joking, or I am misinterpreting what you are saying, otherwise I can't disagree with you more. If what you are saying is true then nearly everyone on BP is wasting their time, as they aren't buying apartment buildings with at least 150 units in them. I know some very successful investors that completely disagree with you, and I think that Ken McElroy and Grant Cardone would disagree with you as well, as I'm pretty sure that neither of them started off buying 150 unit buildings. Now Ken McElroy only has like a billion dollars in assets, maybe you know more than he does. What's funny is that many people, in my experience, do quite well only buying single family homes. I know a guy who owns over 500 houses, and he's been doing this for like 30 years. I myself have done well investing only in singles and small multis. If you are buying 150 unit buildings, you're competing with larger companies for $60 million+ deals in many markets. I think it's great if you can do business in that space, but that's extremely limiting, and I would guess that the cap rates are probably lower at that level, especially now. I've got a deal right now that I'm looking at that's 1/10th of what you're talking about, that is offering close to a 20% IRR, including high-quality management.

See my post above. Many investors start in the small space because either they cant find syndicators to buy bigger ones or they just want to do it on their own. Thats great that you are looking at a deal for 20% IRR. Most of our deals are in the low 20's as well. While you are competing with larger companies, there is no surging of price since everyones numbers are so good. More jockeying over terms and slight price increases. I have seen smaller properties trade for much higher than the numbers allowed because it was small and had some guy who just wanted to buy his first property and didn't care if it cash flowed. Or because people can afford to tolerate a lower cash flow. At the bigger properties, there is more at stake and investors have to get close to the returns they proclaimed or the sponsor will get fired and/or sued. Most people will not invest in syndication's at low rates of return.

So, in summary, buy small if you must but be aware of the risk you are taking. If you plan on syndicating your own deals, i still recommend you go passively your first time just to pop your cherry in a safer environment. You have a much greater chance of getting your capital returned to you in full in 3-4 years if you invest with a syndicate than doing it on your own the first time. Then from there, absolutely buy what you can afford and claw your way up. 

Happy Investing.!

Post: What is stopping you from investing in multifamily?

Joseph BramantePosted
  • Developer
  • Houston, TX
  • Posts 157
  • Votes 132
Originally posted by @Todd Dexheimer:

@Troy Whitney Read Sam Zells book "Am I being too subtle" He talks about buying smaller deals as well. In this market there is great value in the 10-100 unit range. That is an are that many investors like Joseph scoff at, but the truth is there are a lot of good deals to be found and competition is less. Right now investors in the 1-6, maybe 8 unit and the 150+ unit are fighting tooth and nail for deals and are battling for the last penny to be found. The beauty of the 10-100 unit range (especially the 15-30 units) is that there are a lot of mom and pops and retiring folks ready to sell and willing to sell with financing or a portion of financing to the buyer. There has been a lot of poor advice in this thread

That is certainly one opinion. I'm assuming you operate in the 15-30 unit space.

Let me offer another opinion.  I find there is little value in the small deals for the following reasons:

1) loan amount is too small to be attractive to many lenders so the terms are not as competitive. Also because the loan is so small, it is most often recourse. Meaning it has the greatest consequence if the investor screws up. 

2) to few units to spread the expenses over until you get over 75 units., roughly

3)can't afford full time maintenance and property managers

4) Properties below $4M have more competition since more people can afford them. More competition means higher prices which leads to somebody overpaying and being stuck with a non cashflowing property on a full recourse loan. 

I started at 26 units, then purchased a 61 unit, 101 unit, 137 unit and currently in negotiations to build a 250 unit. I have also bid on several properties over 200 units and a few portfolios of over 1,000 units. So while I started in the small unit space, i quickly grew out of it, thus I am qualified to comment on both. The main difference I find as you rise in unit count is the sophistication of the competition. While there are fewer buyers for the bigger properties, the buyers they do have tend to be more sophisticated than the guys buying the smaller ones. Just like an NFL coach is more sophisticated than your high school football coach. The stakes are much higher so the qualifications must be much higher also. They are often investing with capital from trust funds and other equity groups that have to meet certain financial targets. 

Most investors cut their teeth in the small property space and claw their way up to the bigger properties for the reasons I mentioned above. I have yet to meet an investor who started in the small property space and "chose" to stay there.

Post: Multifamily for first deal?

Joseph BramantePosted
  • Developer
  • Houston, TX
  • Posts 157
  • Votes 132

@Brady Carpenter you need to buy Dave Lindahls book, Multifamily Millions. It will help you a lot with your underwriting and general knowledge. 

Post: What is stopping you from investing in multifamily?

Joseph BramantePosted
  • Developer
  • Houston, TX
  • Posts 157
  • Votes 132
Originally posted by @Troy Whitney:

Joseph - are you saying that you recommend that if an investor wants to invest in say a 20-30 unit building out of state, that they manage it themselves?  I live in Seattle, and own 11 properties in Philadelphia, and have a project/property manager that I work with.  I give him free rent in one of my multis and he runs around for me.  Not all of my properties are cash cows, but as a whole, my portfolio performs decently.  Most of the properties I have bought have needed extensive work and in a number of cases, full renovations.  I bought them all site unseen.

My business partner are now looking at syndicating one or more deals in a totally different state.  It seems to me that the key is having the right management in place, rather than being able to drive to the property yourself.   A good management company makes all the difference.  I assume you don't disagree.

Whenever I say "manage" I am referring to "asset management". There are two types of management. Property Management and Asset Management. One school of thought is to learn everything there is about property management, get all of your certifications, and manage all of your properties. In my opinion, its a slower way to grow since you are very distracted with the day to day of property management and can't focus on managing the asset. These individuals tend to slowly acquire properties and grow their management company. They tend to be micro managers so running the day to day works for them. They put on their asset manager hat when it is time to buy a property, raise capital, or refinance/sale, but are typically not well versed in the underwriting of properties and strategies. The other school of thought is to hire an experienced property manager on a contract basis, typically 3-5% of the gross receipts of the property, and let them take care of the day to day while you (the asset manager) are reviewing reports, setting and tracking budgets, and doing the overall planning for the property. You might visit the property a couple times a year but spend most of your time working remote. You are well trained in underwritting, have extensive network of lenders and investors, monitor the market for rental trends, and responsible for the financial planning of the property (when to sell or refi). When your property management fees exceed the salary of a regional property manager, thats when you either A) fire the mgmt company and bring it inhouse, or B) buy the mgmt company

I was the later, an asset manager who used a small mgmt company with 75 years of industry and market experience to manager all of my properties and then bought them out last year to bring management in house. 

I would never recommend anyone buy anything less than 150 units. It will consume too much of your time for very little money. I recommend passively invest in deals greater than 150 until you can afford to buy one yourself. 

I hope I answered your question. 

Post: I HAVE INVESTORS BUT HOW DO I STRUCTURE THE DEAL

Joseph BramantePosted
  • Developer
  • Houston, TX
  • Posts 157
  • Votes 132
Ivan Correa yes. Keep your group under 5 ppl and have an existing relationship with all of them and you shouldn't need to do a formal Syndication. If all of the investors are new with no prior relation, you should probably get a syndication just to CYA. I have dont then for as cheap at 10k all in.

Post: What is stopping you from investing in multifamily?

Joseph BramantePosted
  • Developer
  • Houston, TX
  • Posts 157
  • Votes 132
Originally posted by @Michael Evans:

Hey @Joseph Bramante,

Currently my credit score is 750+ and I have $10k plus that I've saved so far for investing. I'd love to leverage my credit score and the money I have to get into multifamily properties. I'm not sure if I should find another market in the state where prices are more affordable for me to start or do it locally and try to find partners. What would you recommend? 

Best,

Mike

*P.S. I think multifamily syndications are really interesting! Would RE crowdfunding count as a type of syndication? 

 Michael,

Love the energy and enthusiasm. I recommend you check out the Single Family forums to learn how to grow that 10k into 100k. From there, you can invest passively in multifmaily, or continue growing your money in SF until you have enough to buy a deal yourself. I recommend the passive approach first. Your credit score has little to do with anything unless you are trying to syndicate the offering yourself. 

Crowdfunding syndications typically only fund 20-30% of the deal. They won't fund 100%. At least not that I am aware of. I have only researched this briefly last year but maybe things have changed. 

Post: What is stopping you from investing in multifamily?

Joseph BramantePosted
  • Developer
  • Houston, TX
  • Posts 157
  • Votes 132
Originally posted by @Sri Sathya:
As a newbee here, I don't know the basics of multi family property.can you give some ideas on its basics and how I and few of my friends could stray this?

Check out this resource from BP

https://www.biggerpockets.com/hubs/property-types

Post: What is stopping you from investing in multifamily?

Joseph BramantePosted
  • Developer
  • Houston, TX
  • Posts 157
  • Votes 132
Originally posted by @Cherron Lucas:

hello, me and my husband want to start investing in multi- units. What is the best way to get financing? My husband isn't a handy guy? So I need to network of people

 I am assuming your first deal will be smaller than $5M, so that would likely be a local bank loan. Contact a few real estate brokers on loopnet and ask them for a referral to a mortgage broker. They will shop the debt for you once you identify a property and give you a few options to chose from. Once you get established, you will have a few lenders you can go direct to and save the fee, but even with our network of lenders, I prefer to just negotiate a lower rate with our debt broker for repeat service. He manages the lender for me and allows me to focus on the due diligence.  

Post: What is stopping you from investing in multifamily?

Joseph BramantePosted
  • Developer
  • Houston, TX
  • Posts 157
  • Votes 132
Originally posted by @Michael Swan:

Hi all,

I told my  story on a recent BP podcast 238 and I have not invested in a syndication and have only used family money and a few of my personal friends have invested on one of my latest 21 unit apartment complexes in Painesville, Ohio.  I have been treading slowly in regards to syndication etc...

Right now I have 109 front doors in 7 apartment complexes and 7 single family in NE Ohio.  I would highly advise anyone interested in investing in true multifamily to get David Lindahl's Multifamily Millions.  The apartment complexes that my PM has followed those methods in that book have done wildly well in about 2 years of ownership for the longest owned complexes.  Some of these complexes we have owned for a year or less and we have repositioned them nicely so far too.   I don't belong to David Lindahl's organization and have no ties to them.

I would also agree that your PM is soooooooooooo important to implement your plan.  I do have a day job, play hockey twice a week, coach baseball, and DO have time to manage my PM.

"Whatever the mind can conceive and believe it can achieve."

Napolean Hill in his book Think and Grow Rich.

Swanny

 That book 'Multifamily Millions" was one of the first books I ever read on MF and how I got started. Love it. Congrats on your success!