Yes I do still have the cover, great idea.
As far as I know she has no proof it was icicles. No she didn't notify me which is why I doubt her story plus she is an entitled old bag. The icicle would have had to have been massive.
My strong suspicion IS that it was crushed from a heavy person standing on it and as it is located directly below where their sattelite dish was installed......
Why go through the stress of it....well her lawyer demanded twice the security deposit, so almost 3k PLUS attorneys fees. No way. Not happening. If he was just asking for the amount withheld I probably would have negotiated that with him, but he thinks he is going to nail me under the states consumer fraud protection act.
Yes the damage was to the top, but the edge of the top, so it could have been a vehicle or a person. It was over 500 dollars to replace it.
I am feeling good about this. I will come back and let you all know how it goes. Still a few weeks out.