Will,
As you have already learn, Anderson is not really a suburb of Indianapolis. Anderson is in Madison County versus Indianapolis in Marion County.
However, you can find some good buys in Anderson but it is definitely tricky. I used to have one of my satellite legal offices in Anderson for about 6 years. It is primarily a rental market. The revitalization in the city has been improving over the past 8-10 years but has been really, really slow. When General Motors left the community in the late 80s, the city lost over 27,000 jobs. It, in essence, became a ghost town, as a majority of the population all worked for GM.
You are starting to see more and more development on the I-69 corridor between the Northeast side of Indianapolis to Anderson. Years ago, I was part of the team that helped to attract the Nestle facility on I-69, along with other industries in the Flagship Enterprise Center (the technology incubator).
Anderson still has a strong presence within the automotive and logistics industries. More and more international automotive-related companies are targeting the Anderson area, which has helped to jump start the revitalization again. The cost of living in Madison County is much lower than compared to Marion County. "Live in Madison County, work in Marion County" used to be the motto but that is slowly changing now with the State of Indiana Economic Development Corporation and Department of Transportation targeted funding and focus on the I-69 corridor. But many individuals still do commute to Indianapolis. It's basically less than a 30-minute commute from Anderson to the Northside of Indianapolis.
The Paramount theater is beautiful! It was restored about 6-7 years ago. If you haven't been in it, you most certainly should when you are in the area. The parimutuel horse track and casino, Hoosier Downs owned and operated by Churchill Downs, is a significant attraction to local patrons given the local mall is basically non-existent. Many residents will now visit the outdoor mall off of Exit 210 on I-69. This mall also attracts a great deal of residents from the Town of Pendleton, also in Madison County and closer to the Indianapolis area.
Best of Luck in the Anderson area. Happy Investing!