Hi Henry, Are you limiting yourself to only Huntington? There are plenty of other areas that may offer better returns where the taxes will be lower. Everyone also has there own goals which determine whether they want to flip or whether they want to buy multi family properties. If you are looking for faster ROI, you can certainly make money on LI flipping homes. On the other hand if you want to build long term wealth you could always look to purchase multi family homes and rent them out.
Have you tried using the house flipping calculator or the rental property calculator under the tool drop down?
Also, have you considered purchasing out of state? There are many Real Estate Investment companies that offer minimum investments and many show between 10-20% ROI. The one I have worked with is on the higher end of that scale.
In the end you have to do what you think is going to be best for you.
If I can help out in any other way, please feel free to PM me. I am always looking for new clients and to help them achieve their goals.