Originally posted by @Elvira Longoria:
@Joe Cassandra how did you over rehab?
- "Oh, this bathroom needs a full gut. The shower isn't HGTV worthy..."
- "Oh, this roof is 10 years old, no buyer will want this, we need to replace it..."
- "I don't like these cabinet fronts, I could paint them for $500...naw, let's replace the fronts so they look better for $2,800."
Overrehabbing you're doing more than you need to...usually for vain reasons and not smart business reasons.
Now, what we do:
1) Look at comps and ONLY get to their level. If their master baths are inserts...leave them as inserts. Don't gut and re-tile and spend thousands.
2) If a roof or hvac is not at useful life (even 13 years old like our last house). DO NOT replace. Use as negotiating piece during DD. Replacing it will not get you more money. The buyer will just find something else for $5,000 to complain about for you to fix.
3) Don't buy expensive stuff. One of our first flips, we got one of those fancy standalone tubs because we thought it would boost ARV. Cost $2,500 for everything for it, did not get that money back.
4) Bank on STAGING to make house sell, and not expensive stuff. Don't add can lights for 'effect.' Don't add a sliding backdoor to 'let more light in.' (big mistake). Bring in $10 lamps to add light. Change the light bulbs to brighter ones to let more light in for $20.
It doesn't mean 'cut corners' and 'hide things.'
It means stop trying to make a house to impress people. You're in flipping to make money.
The more things you start in house, the more problems you'll find and have to fix.