@Tim Burke
Welcome to the Area. I live in Ithaca and hold income property in Cortland and Groton while working at acquiring more in Ithaca. These markets Cortland, Groton, Dryden, Ithaca are very different in rents, demographics, and many other things. You will find that some of the places in Ithaca rival property prices in Manhattan on a price per sq foot basis. If you go just a few blocks the prices are different so you should work with someone that knows the area.
I also run the local RE MeetUp group in Ithaca and I'm a licensed RE agent in the area. I only deal with individuals who are either having issues paying their mortgage or investors. Our vacancy rate in the city of ithaca is 0.8% (That's a crazy number), our town is less than 4% and the city is composed of 65% rentals. The other number that you should be aware of is that our average home values have shot up 40% over the past 10 years. That's even with the crash figured in.
Ithaca is an Outlayer statistically, there are many factors that influence this. The first and major are the schools (Cornell and IC) as they are major employers as well as accept many students.
I belong to a network of 10,000 investors nationwide. The reason that I tell you this is because this weekend I am going to be in NYC at the regional office giving a presentation and won't be available until monday.
Let me know if I can help with any place that you may want to relax, eat, and explore in town.
Jesse