@James Park
My situation is kind of similar. I started buying properties in the Bay Area in 2012, and actually wanted to stay local for all of my future purchases as well. I figured, I was buying good properties in good neighborhoods, so why not milk that for as long as I could?
Unfortunately, the returns all but dried up this year, so I also felt stuck. I had some capital, and wanted to keep investing... but didn't have a market to turn to. So, I looked into areas further out in the Central Valley, but the returns weren't too spectacular... Long story short, I went out of state so that I could keep investing. The returns are pretty good, but I am sacrificing on "quality" to get the cash flow. I used to only want to invest in A++ neighborhoods, but I've adjusted, and my portfolio is a blend now.
I guess sitting on the sidelines is another option, but that isn't much fun, is it? ;)
My strategy is to keep buying out of state until the next market correction, or whenever the deals start to make sense again in my local area. If the opportunity presents itself in the future, I'll re-focus locally and back the truck up! Definitely don't want to miss another opportunity to invest in the Bay Area!