@Account Closed
I would have to lean towards scenario B personally.... I'm here in the Youngstown area as well, Boardman actually, and though I agree that we are very unlikely going to see an appreciation in most all of the surrounding areas I do think that for the most part the values won't drop significantly over a short period of time. We don't and haven't really ever had the large swings that other areas have had in property valuations as we just really never have a demand change, it's been pretty darn constant even through the crash we were only slightly affected as we were already in a "depressed" area. Depending on where your properties are of course, I'm going to take a guess and say that you've got them on the West Side being as the prices would match and it seems that for whatever reason in my experience the Canfield guys dabble the most on the West Side of Youngstown. So if that's true, I'd hold them.... the West side has been very stable and at those prices you should be able to make the numbers work with rent & your cash out refi so the long term strategy makes the most sense for you. Though I do question your plan with the 50k cash out through the refi.... I'd talk to your banker to make sure they realistically think that you will be able to pull something close to that number out on the property. In my experience the appraisals on cash out in the city have been a bit lower than market value and then 75% LTV or less at that... so you might be looking at pulling 35-40k out instead of the 50k that you're hoping.
If you do have a great cash-out situation with a banker, certainly let me know who you used as I'd love to find a better one for future properties for myself.