Hi Scott,
I'd think Good, Bad and Ugly would be different for ever Franchisee and entirely based on their business model, so not entirely sure I can specifically address. The bad for all of us is obviously franchise costs! Of course no one wants to pay Franchisee fees, but if you come up with a better way let me know and I'll do that!
Sounds like your concerned about performance within in the appointments and ability to buy at levels most of us do, is that correct? You think all 800 some franchisees are salesmen? Reality is with a little knowledge and structure your not actually selling anything, I don't think for a moment that I'm a salesman. We have a quote that sales is a "broadway play put on by a psychiatrist" and your 3/4 of the way there if you have trust and confidence with the seller. It's about getting free flow of information to figure out if we are going to be an opportunity for them or not. If the seller has no pain, or motivation to sell at a discount, it's not the right option for them and nothing you say or so will get them down to a price that will make sense for you.
The fact that your an honest person and people can perseve that is perfect, that's the main point! I've been highly impressed with the values and culture HomeVestors has established. There's a lot of shady investors out there, and you don't have to play games with the seller, just facilitate the model HomeVestors has in place and you can buy at 65% of ARV minutes the cost to repair over and over again. Youve seen that first hand with the properties you've bought from HomeVestors franchisees in your market. And how much did they make at closing when you bought from them!?!
There's another aspect within your scenario that I think should be mentioned. In RE investment you can increase your profit in one of 2 ways, buy deeper and reduce the cost of rehabs. With your knowledge and background maybe you don't need to buy as deep as others? Just a thought as I'm not much a fan of rehabs and certainly not as efficient as I need to be, so I must buy super deep.
Happy to chat on a call a little if you need. Don't know if I helped any, but it's not about getting you to join HomeVestors more than getting you the appropriate information for you to make that decision.
Let me know if you have any other questions.