Hi @Trent Barga - thanks for posting this here. I think there are some good points brought up in some of these comments. One thing I would caution against (because I have done it myself) is when I get so close to the finish line after doing so much work, I start "wanting to make it work" despite numbers and new data suggesting otherwise. I can't make the decision for you, but I would suggest the following:
1. If you haven't already, take a day to breathe and then dedicate some time to analyze some other properties.
2. Check the comps in the area for this particular property. Are you paying top dollar given the condition?
3. If you do get it under contract, do NOT waive any contingencies. Get a real quote from a contractor and a home inspection during the investigation contingency period so you know how much work you are looking at.
4. Make sure you don't walk away without any cash in the bank. If you do decide to pull the trigger, try to make sure you have 5-10% of the purchase price in the bank to handle "whatever comes up". Oftentimes, there are surprises lurking that don't show up until after we record...
All of that being said, I recognize that B+/A neighborhoods prove to be super-safe investments given the tenants that usually are able to afford the units. Take your time on this, do your due diligence, and don't force anything. Better to start over than become cash poor in a poor investment. :)
Here if you need anything along the way!