Skip to content
×
PRO
Pro Members Get Full Access!
Get off the sidelines and take action in real estate investing with BiggerPockets Pro. Our comprehensive suite of tools and resources minimize mistakes, support informed decisions, and propel you to success.
Advanced networking features
Market and Deal Finder tools
Property analysis calculators
Landlord Command Center
$0
TODAY
$69.00/month when billed monthly.
$32.50/month when billed annually.
7 day free trial. Cancel anytime
Already a Pro Member? Sign in here
Pick markets, find deals, analyze and manage properties. Try BiggerPockets PRO.
x
All Forum Categories
All Forum Categories
Followed Discussions
Followed Categories
Followed People
Followed Locations
Market News & Data
General Info
Real Estate Strategies
Landlording & Rental Properties
Real Estate Professionals
Financial, Tax, & Legal
Real Estate Classifieds
Reviews & Feedback

All Forum Posts by: Frank S.

Frank S. has started 105 posts and replied 853 times.

Post: Garage floor paint/epoxy

Frank S.Posted
  • Specialist
  • Chicago, IL
  • Posts 870
  • Votes 345

I'm glad I followed this post.  Geat info.

Post: Kiyosaki Why the rich are getting richer tax ?

Frank S.Posted
  • Specialist
  • Chicago, IL
  • Posts 870
  • Votes 345

@Jason D., that's great!  You got a great handle on it.  Congrats!  It's great your wife is taking care of the kids.

You may have this already, but if not, talk to your CPA about a spousal IRA. Roth cash must stay there for 5 years, but you can tap into it unlike a tax-deffered one.

Disclosure: The following is  written on the fly, spelling errors are intentional, semantics are for everyone's enjoyment.

Honestly, what truly bothers me is to see the horrible advice given by Bob. I care about people's well-being, I truly do.  

There are many, many ways to tackle that vogus claim, here is one. 

Note #1.  I am strongly biased as I can stand the guy.

Cost basis: $275,00 at 27.5 years, land $125,000, each property cost $400,000

It would take about $4,000,000 in encumbred property to make that 10K loss (P&L) happen.  At 30% down payment, that's $1.2M. For someone making $100K that's some serious savings.   See note #1.

What do lenders look for when assesing the performance of encumbered properties in the P&L? The "P".

I just got a refi on a cash purchase, the lender looked under all rocks possible to release 70% ARV. It was tourtorous. This was a $155K ARV property producing $2.6K. It was purchased at $120K and $8K repairs. It would be highly unlikely, if not impossible, to get 4M in loans if all loose money. At least with that lender. See note #1.

Then, why is this dude making those claims?  Is it done to generate hype before passing the collection basket. I don't know, you be the judge.

Class #1 – Free Advice

Class #2 – Paid Advice, $500

Class #3 – Paid Advice $30K to $45K

What about the bankruptcies?  Perhaps he believed his own financial advice fantasies.  See note #1.

Best of luck to all, 

Post: Kiyosaki Why the rich are getting richer tax ?

Frank S.Posted
  • Specialist
  • Chicago, IL
  • Posts 870
  • Votes 345
Originally posted by @Jason D.:
@Frank Sanchez sorry frank, but a lot of what you wrote is, also, factually incorrect. If the OP wants advice on how to minimize his tax liability, he should speak with a CPA

 What a nice rabbit hole I got myself into. It's kind of fun,  tho. 

In my opinion,  the post was about Bob's book example and how that applies to reality. In summary,  the example in the book is useless, for it's vague and unreasonable, much like all of his fictional books. That's my personal and honest opinion.

I'm curious -  and not in a confrontational way. Please, illustrate the incorrect statements as this may help others- and myself.  Perhaps, it's matter of semantics, which are easily clarified. Keep in mind the intent and context of the example given in the book. 

Take care, 

Frank

Post: Kiyosaki Why the rich are getting richer tax ?

Frank S.Posted
  • Specialist
  • Chicago, IL
  • Posts 870
  • Votes 345
Originally posted by @Joe Splitrock:
Originally posted by @Eamonn McElroy:

@Frank S. "Ask yourself, what would it take to have 10 properties loosing $100,000 per year? Don't you want to make some money?"

A tax loss isn't the same as an overall, holistic loss (ROI).

A tax loss, or a breakeven rather, is the optimal tax position. 

To your point, I have a tax loss on my rental properties every year, but bank plenty of profit regardless.

Likewise, BRRR is great to achieve that.

Post: Kiyosaki Why the rich are getting richer tax ?

Frank S.Posted
  • Specialist
  • Chicago, IL
  • Posts 870
  • Votes 345
Originally posted by @Eamonn McElroy:

@Frank S.

The initial purpose of your response appears to have been to question the validity of Robert Kiyosaki.  I didn't argue against that as I don't hold a strong opinion either way.

Then you veered off on a tangent and implied properties with a tax loss are losing money (i.e. cash flow negative).  This isn't always true...

Then you implied tax loss (i.e. benefit) is lost if the taxpayer is not a real estate professional... It is deferred, not lost.

"Tax shelter is one of the four ways to make money in RE, not the only one. That's beyond the purpose of this response." [Emphasis Added]

Yes.....that first sentence was my whole message in response to you, it appears to have been lost in translation.

Maybe that's the difference,  I do hold a strong position against misleading, detrimental,  and incorrect  advice, like Bob's fantasies. 

Post: Kiyosaki Why the rich are getting richer tax ?

Frank S.Posted
  • Specialist
  • Chicago, IL
  • Posts 870
  • Votes 345
Originally posted by @Eamonn McElroy:

@Frank S. "Ask yourself, what would it take to have 10 properties loosing $100,000 per year? Don't you want to make some money?"

A tax loss isn't the same as an overall, holistic loss (ROI).

A tax loss, or a breakeven rather, is the optimal tax position. 

Tax shelter is one of the four ways to make money in RE, not the only one.  That's beyond the purpose of this response. 

Post: Kiyosaki Why the rich are getting richer tax ?

Frank S.Posted
  • Specialist
  • Chicago, IL
  • Posts 870
  • Votes 345

Kiyosaki is a buffoon, I wouldn't trust anything on his books. In fact,  research the flaws within his work of fiction.

To start,  nobody pays taxes based on the Marginal Tax Rate on the first dollar,  we pay the Effective Tax Rate.  Many tout that same story because most don't know what's the difference. 

Get this instead, Every Landlord's Tax Deduction Guide by NOLO. Read it a few times,  buy the new book each year,  and learn from a good CPA.

Then,  recall Recapture Tax bites at 25% without 1031s.

Read Brandon's (above) articles and seminars.  He has some of the best information I have seen.

That statement is illogical, 

Ask yourself,  what would it take to have 10 properties loosing $100,000 per year? Don't you want to make some money? 

Then, for how long is that sustainable? 

Who would loan someone 10 mortgages if they all lose $10,000 per year with only a $100,000 salary? 

If they make money,  and 10k per unit is only depreciation.  Then,  the tax he describes fades away if the person is not a Real Estate Professional.

And so it goes.. 

You can discredit those malicious arguments with knowledge. 

I wish you the best,  I simply can't stand that clown. 

Frank

Post: Rental Property - LLC?

Frank S.Posted
  • Specialist
  • Chicago, IL
  • Posts 870
  • Votes 345

Post rent/cost numbers on the condo, people will comment.

Use CPI to see if you may be better off selling it.

LLCs are overrated for people with only a few units. Umbrella and Landlord Insurance may do. I ignore how many units you have.

“High Growth” is profit chasing. That's '07 again. Don't be the last one holding the money bag. Appreciation is nice, but too risky. 

Post: Share your contractors to show your appreciation (Chicago area).

Frank S.Posted
  • Specialist
  • Chicago, IL
  • Posts 870
  • Votes 345

It's hard. 

I deal with many professional contractors through my job, large firms. They are efficient,  reliable,  insured,  licensed,  and expensive. I can't use them for my rental business.  It's shocking to see the difference between both worlds. 

Good luck with your research.  It's a revolving door. 

Post: Share your contractors to show your appreciation (Chicago area).

Frank S.Posted
  • Specialist
  • Chicago, IL
  • Posts 870
  • Votes 345

Do you mean, give me your guys contact info? Hmmm, let me get back to you on that one...