@David Bergmann awesome job my friend. We have employed this strategy ourselves several times and any time you can cash flow $2000 a month and possibly pay the place off in 6 - 7 years you have hit a home run. Couple watch outs you should address:
1. Maintenance - even though you remodeled it down to the studs older homes have more maintenance. I would use a 20% - 25% monthly reserve of revenues. In saying that I don’t know if you replaced the roof, foundation, or other high priced items
2. You property tax bill will most likely increase if the neighborhood is changing for the best. Towns love to find revenue.
3. Immediately, do not pass go, immediately find out what is the current situation with STR’s and find out if you can get a permit. If it’s easy get it tomorrow. You will insulate yourself from any changing legislation. I have found in several markets that they are willing to grandfather in your current situation.
Lastly, go do 5 more and retire, start a band, or go skydiving.