@Georges A.
Ooops.. I just saw how you mentioned the podcast as the place you got the idea ^^
By the way, I was wondering how you figured out your numbers? As a newbie, I was trying to do the calculations myself but I wasn't able to make them work.
For the Cap Rate, according to what I've read on BP:
http://www.biggerpockets.com/renewsblog/2010/06/30/introduction-to-real-estate-analysis-investing/#comment-153456
You take the NOI and divide by the price you paid (including closing / repairs):
EGI = $28,680 ($2,390 x12)
2013 Expenses = $16,821 (according to the statement - 59% of EGI)
NOI = $11,859 (no vacancy considered)
Cap Rate ($11,859 / $189,500) = 6.2%
Is this what you meant by the Cash on Cash in your post?
Cash on Cash, from what I understood, was the Cash Flow / Investment Basis.
$42,500 (Down Payment) + $19,500 (Repair + Closing) = $62,000 Investment Basis
Cash flow = NOI - Debt Services (I just calculated 25% down on 30 year fixed at 7% - about $850 / mo)
Cash flow = $11,859 - $10,200 = $1,659
Cash on Cash: 2.7%
For the ROI: Using JScott's spreadsheet (the author about the post above), I calculated about 4.8%
Anyways, I'm sure you're busy figuring out if you want to make the deal or not, but if you ever have some time, I'd be curious to know how you ended up with your figures and what mistake I made in my calculations.
Thanks!