@Jonah Slove congrats on you & your fiancé! Y’all have a great problem on your hands that most people dream of.
I subscribe to the “small but mighty” idea by Coach Carson. I’d prefer owning outright a handful of properties that can cashflow $1500-$2000/month (which is even lower than your $2,500/month).
It’s whatever you & your fiancé think is best though if I were in your position, I’d be just fine with selling & buying 3 properties around $250,000 purchase price ($750,000 total) with a few hundred thousand left over. Then rent each of them out for $2,000/month to tenants (minus property management fees) which would give you roughly an extra $70,000/year.
That’s my opinion, and it’s why my fiancé & I plan on selling 2 of our own properties and just paying off a couple of the others. We’ll be do short term rentals on the fully paid off properties so the cashflow will be higher than $2000/month. That might be another option for you & your fiancé to think about!
best of luck!!