Olivia,
It's very unfortunate that you have had a bad experience with the company you selected in Akron, OH. However, I would hate for this experience to ruin it for all the others that could possibly profit your investment. You want a property manager that navigates the market effortless (believe it or not size should not matter)! Systems are the most important aspect of property management: this is key to helping your properties perform in the best way imaginable. Communication, transparency, customer service, etc. should all be facets taken into consideration. That's why cheaper isn't always better. I love to tell owners compare apples to apples and not oranges to apples. That's why small, medium, or large company doesn't matter. We have to be fair when we are evaluating the companies and ourselves. I would hate for you to find out why one property manager was cheaper/worse than the other – once it's too late. Please make sure you do your research! Experience Matters! I would recommend interviewing local property managers and seeing a few things:
Do the company's values align with yours? ...
Does the company culture fit your personality? ...
Are the team members people you'd love to work with? ...
How long have you all been in business? ...
Is there a customer service department dedicated to clients and that's their only job? ...
What 'In-House' services do you provide and what do you outsource? ...
How many property do your company manage has a whole? ...
How many properties do your company manage in the city that I am interested in (in your case Fayetteville, AR, Fort Worth, TX or Oklahoma City, OK)?
What is your average lease term? ...
Do you have a renewal department who's job is only to focus on renewals? ...
What is your average resident length of stay? ...
Do you all have resident surveys? ...
What is your average length of vacancy? ...
And then add your flavor of questions in here ...
Best of Luck,