In Rochester, we have a...
3 bedroom on the corner of Winbourne and Scottsville rd that is rented to students for $1200
Two 2 bedrooms that rent for 800 each on the corner of west high terrace and wellington
a 3 bedroom on Monica Street that rents for $1050
A three bedroom on Devon road that rents for $1200
There are 5 houses listed on Zillow for over $1200 on S. Plymouth and Barton. All of which are currently rented to students.
http://www.zillow.com/homes/for_rent/house,condo,a...
Below is a list of 48 homes that have sold in the past 3 years that have sold for under $66k in the area. These are just the NORMAL Single Family on MLS sales, not including REO, multi-families, or off Market deals...
http://nys.fusionmls.com/DotNet/Pub/EmailView.aspx...
Streets like Devon Road, Winbourne, Genesee Park, Weldon are minutes away from the University. Although it is rare, I have seen students as far as Brooks and Genesee Park Blvd but @Shannon Sadik is right in the sense that you will not find many students who will rent North of Brooks Avenue. As of now, student rentals are limited to South Plymouth, Barton Street, Winbourne, Devon Road, Weldon Road, and in random spots South of Brooks Ave-closer to the University.
I have found some pretty good tenants in the 19th ward including a couple who both work for the UR and rent on Midvale Terrace, a single mom who works for UR that rents on Wellington, and a few groups of students who rent near Winbourne.
You will find better tenants in the South Wedge/Highland/Swillburg area but you have to accept a lower return on investment. It is a lot harder to find enough profitable deals in the area to accumulate a sizable portfolio.
@Shannon SadikWhere have you found success? What areas would you recommend investing in?