So a lot of people have been suggesting using a property manager. I have used two property management companies. The first was pretty bad (it took them five months to get a nearly turn-key rental on the rental market). They were fairly highly rated, and performed well on my extensive screening interview (we went over an hour).
The second was even worse. His company has a 5-star rating, and upon reading the fine print I discovered he has a non-disparagement clause in his contract. I *should* have caught that before I signed on. The owner of the PM company ALSO owns the maintenance company that does all of their work. As an aside, when I ended the contract with that firm, they mysteriously had maintenance fees that equaled the amount of money in my holding account (nearly $1500!).
Since I've been self-managing, my tenant has been FAR happier, and my maintenance costs have gone way down. I also manage property in my home town, so I am very familiar with what it takes to manage a property. I just have not encountered this particular situation before, and was looking for suggestions.
I plan to continue self-managing this property from afar. I was just hoping for some constructive, helpful suggestions on how to proceed with this unusual situation.
I do have a preferred vendors list that I have been curating since I've taken on management.
It's kind of frustrating to see all of the negative comments. I *thought* this was a supportive, helpful community. But what I'm seeing is a lot of people making assumptions and finger wagging.
I have requested a police welfare check, and am awaiting a response.