@Jerad Bailey , as I said previously, you basically have an awesome "flip" that would have created a huge profit for yourself, but the issue is the tenant in the house for 16 more months. You can't market it for the typical reasons a family would want a house (i.e. great features and location) because a family can't move in. Since it can't be enjoyed as a family house, anyone purchasing it would have to consider the income it produces and I'd expect to get WAY less than what comparable owner occupant houses would get.
I can only presume you chose to rent it out rather than selling because you were thinking/hoping/planning on more appreciation, but you have a lot of equity tied up for the income you are describing.
The way I see it, you're between a rock and a hard place. If it were me, I'd try to figure out a way to get the tenant out (legally and ethically) and sell and use the proceeds for a property or properties that have better ROI.
Just my $0.02