Skip to content
×
PRO
Pro Members Get Full Access!
Get off the sidelines and take action in real estate investing with BiggerPockets Pro. Our comprehensive suite of tools and resources minimize mistakes, support informed decisions, and propel you to success.
Advanced networking features
Market and Deal Finder tools
Property analysis calculators
Landlord Command Center
$0
TODAY
$69.00/month when billed monthly.
$32.50/month when billed annually.
7 day free trial. Cancel anytime
Already a Pro Member? Sign in here
Pick markets, find deals, analyze and manage properties. Try BiggerPockets PRO.
x
All Forum Categories
All Forum Categories
Followed Discussions
Followed Categories
Followed People
Followed Locations
Market News & Data
General Info
Real Estate Strategies
Landlording & Rental Properties
Real Estate Professionals
Financial, Tax, & Legal
Real Estate Classifieds
Reviews & Feedback

All Forum Posts by: Adrian Stamer

Adrian Stamer has started 14 posts and replied 300 times.

Post: $300,000 in student loan debt

Adrian Stamer
Pro Member
Posted
  • Real Estate Investor & Agent
  • Richmond, VA
  • Posts 319
  • Votes 167

If I was determined to follow my expensive dream like this (maybe think of it in terms of wanting to buy an expensive luxury item like a boat or a car) then I would put off acquiring it until I have built a better base of income and savings. Maybe delay the education a couple of years and buy that duplex anyway... then maybe a second and a third. 

With $300k of student debt hanging over your head simply qualifying to buy additional investment properties will be extremely difficult cause your debt ratios will be totally blown out. 

Post: Should I sell or refinance and pull money out?

Adrian Stamer
Pro Member
Posted
  • Real Estate Investor & Agent
  • Richmond, VA
  • Posts 319
  • Votes 167

If you love your house I would keep your house not sell it. Get a HELOC and use it to buy properties and then pay the line back down with the cash flow. This is how I personally run things

Post: Low Cap Rate and Cash Flow related Confusion?!

Adrian Stamer
Pro Member
Posted
  • Real Estate Investor & Agent
  • Richmond, VA
  • Posts 319
  • Votes 167
I could be wrong but I believe you forgot to multiple by 12 for 12 months of NOI earnings

Cap Rate = $1,119.67 / $210,000 = 0.533%

should be $1,119.67 * 12 months

Originally posted by @Joe Pearson:

So, color me confused. For example, a duplex in Manchester, NH could go for $210k and both units could be rented for a total of $2,400 per month. That means the NOI could be $1,119.67, Cap Rate of 0.533 % and Cash Flow of -$99.33.... Here's the per month numbers I'm looking at with an FHA Loan for 30 years & 3.5% down payment at 4.85% interest:

Expenses:

  • Taxes: $391.67
  • Homeowners Insurance: $66.67
  • PMI: $150
  • Vacancy (5%): $120
  • Repairs (5%): $120
  • CapEx (8%): $192
  • Property Management (10%): $240
  • Mortgage: $1,219
  • (Tenants would pay for utilities)

And... like, this isn't even accounting for Lawn care or Snow removal...

Total Expenses: 2,499.33

NOI = $2,400 - $1,280.33 = $1,119.67

Cap Rate = $1,119.67 / $210,000 = 0.533%

Also, for the 1%, 2%, or 3% rule this comes in at 1.143% = $2,400 / $210,000

So, this is being generous, really. $210k is on the lower side and I'm assuming I'll take care of the lawn/snow.

I'm most confused at how this can really change in any one direction to make it meet the 8% cap rate or the 2% or 3% rule... like the only way I can see it meeting those is by jacking up rent or getting the house for free by a family member. *slams head on desk*

-Joe

Post: How do I make money on a deal with investors involved.

Adrian Stamer
Pro Member
Posted
  • Real Estate Investor & Agent
  • Richmond, VA
  • Posts 319
  • Votes 167
Originally posted by @Matt Popilek:

@adrian stamer I'm not sure how you can determine my risk level with out reviewing my deal. You might want to think about your limiting beliefs. If you automatically assume risk with out knowing the details you might miss out on some really good opportunities.

 Understand completely. That’s why I am saying you aren’t using cap rate properly

Post: How do I make money on a deal with investors involved.

Adrian Stamer
Pro Member
Posted
  • Real Estate Investor & Agent
  • Richmond, VA
  • Posts 319
  • Votes 167
Originally posted by @Matt Popilek:

@adrian stamer - I know how to calculate a cap rate, and CoC. I am using cap rate because that was what I used to review the deal considering CoC is infinite since there is no cash in the deal. Cap Rates are different on every deal.

 A cap rate of 22% would mean it was an extremely risky deal

Post: Rental 50%-Rule vs 30%-Rule on a SFH

Adrian Stamer
Pro Member
Posted
  • Real Estate Investor & Agent
  • Richmond, VA
  • Posts 319
  • Votes 167
Originally posted by @Joe Villeneuve:
Originally posted by @Adrian Stamer:
Originally posted by @Joe Villeneuve:
Originally posted by @Adrian Stamer:
Originally posted by @Joe Villeneuve:
Originally posted by @Adrian Stamer:
Originally posted by @Eric Gamble:

@Joe Villeneuve it seems you are operating in an environment I am moving towards.  When I worked in corporate America I did a great deal of reverse engineering.

@Adrian Stamer I am not attempt to "rock the Rule boat." I understand the rules are for "quick looks." However, with my limited experience, it seems that this rule might be making my thumb "too big" when analyzing SFH where the tenant will more than likely pay for all utilities.

 I agree, once you analyze enough properties you’ll be able to glance at the numbers and short cut mentally even further. I use rent to price ratios a lot more to filter through deals but I also pay attention to the propert type and class when looking at these numbers and adjust a little each way as needed 

I never use rent/price ratios because that ratio doesn't consider taxes, insurance, and a number of other things that are different, and have nothing to do with any ratio.

If you analyze markets, using specific criteria that groups properties without using "fudge factors", the market values define themselves.

 I’m typically operating in a specific geographical location so taxes are always with in a range that is completely corolatted with price. The other numbers are generally within ranges but anyway...

The point I was making when he was saying 30% or 50% rule was you do this to filter through results and then when you find the potentials you actually spreadsheet the numbers and see exactly where they come out. I buy a decent amount of fresh to the market in demand properties so I need to know how much I can offer to beat out competing offers

 If you are truly working in a specific geographical area, and taxes/ins are always within a range, then why do you need to use such a general (guessing) filter like the 30/50 options?

Your knowledge of your specific area should already give you the numbers (actual and tight) and using the 30/50 rules should only blur your results.

Well yes of course, the 50% rule is simply taking gross rents, and stating that 50% of this amount is the NOI. Then multiple by 12 (or skip a step take gross monthly rents and multiply by 6) then divide by whatever cap rate you think is reasonable and compare to sale price. Takes 30 seconds and can do it on my phone anywhere right after I get an email alerting me about the property hitting the market

Then if I get a near match then you spend the time to request the real actual numbers, take the numbers you know to be accurate (don’t always trust the sellers), and really tighten everything down exact as possible. 

Rule of thumbs are just a starting point used to save a bit of time and help rapidly filter listings. They are not something you use and take to investors and say “oh this must work because it fits this rule of thumb”

Shouldn't your specific knowledge eliminate the need for the 30/50 rule?  Doesn't using the 30/50 rule just take you backwards from where your specific knowledge took you? 

 Well again I prefer rents to sales price ratios when doing that quick initial math. But that’s all that it is, quick and initial. Generally it’s aiming for 1% rule and up, so if I glance at a price and see its .5% rent ratio I will skip... but if it’s .9% it’s time to look at the numbers a lot closer. Also if it’s 1.5% then I’m interested but I’m still looking closer because I want to know why. 

Same would apply to 50% rule. If I do the math and the expense ratio to work at the current price would have to be 25% expenses, then it’s generally a hard pass. I look at plenty of offering docs and when an agent tosses together a pro forma and again their expenses only come out to 25%, then you know it’s rather unrealistic which makes the asking price rather unrealistic.

So if you are a wholesaler prepping emails to send to investors, if you are saying 30% expenses then depending on the deal they won’t take you that seriously because your pro forma is unrealistic. Either way, investors always need to do their own numbers, but it’s always a relief when someone sends me a reasonable pro forma versus just the sender thinking they can sell some ********

Post: Rental 50%-Rule vs 30%-Rule on a SFH

Adrian Stamer
Pro Member
Posted
  • Real Estate Investor & Agent
  • Richmond, VA
  • Posts 319
  • Votes 167
Originally posted by @Joe Villeneuve:
Originally posted by @Adrian Stamer:
Originally posted by @Joe Villeneuve:
Originally posted by @Adrian Stamer:
Originally posted by @Eric Gamble:

@Joe Villeneuve it seems you are operating in an environment I am moving towards.  When I worked in corporate America I did a great deal of reverse engineering.

@Adrian Stamer I am not attempt to "rock the Rule boat." I understand the rules are for "quick looks." However, with my limited experience, it seems that this rule might be making my thumb "too big" when analyzing SFH where the tenant will more than likely pay for all utilities.

 I agree, once you analyze enough properties you’ll be able to glance at the numbers and short cut mentally even further. I use rent to price ratios a lot more to filter through deals but I also pay attention to the propert type and class when looking at these numbers and adjust a little each way as needed 

I never use rent/price ratios because that ratio doesn't consider taxes, insurance, and a number of other things that are different, and have nothing to do with any ratio.

If you analyze markets, using specific criteria that groups properties without using "fudge factors", the market values define themselves.

 I’m typically operating in a specific geographical location so taxes are always with in a range that is completely corolatted with price. The other numbers are generally within ranges but anyway...

The point I was making when he was saying 30% or 50% rule was you do this to filter through results and then when you find the potentials you actually spreadsheet the numbers and see exactly where they come out. I buy a decent amount of fresh to the market in demand properties so I need to know how much I can offer to beat out competing offers

 If you are truly working in a specific geographical area, and taxes/ins are always within a range, then why do you need to use such a general (guessing) filter like the 30/50 options?

Your knowledge of your specific area should already give you the numbers (actual and tight) and using the 30/50 rules should only blur your results.

Well yes of course, the 50% rule is simply taking gross rents, and stating that 50% of this amount is the NOI. Then multiple by 12 (or skip a step take gross monthly rents and multiply by 6) then divide by whatever cap rate you think is reasonable and compare to sale price. Takes 30 seconds and can do it on my phone anywhere right after I get an email alerting me about the property hitting the market

Then if I get a near match then you spend the time to request the real actual numbers, take the numbers you know to be accurate (don’t always trust the sellers), and really tighten everything down exact as possible. 

Rule of thumbs are just a starting point used to save a bit of time and help rapidly filter listings. They are not something you use and take to investors and say “oh this must work because it fits this rule of thumb”

Post: What is the income want to achieve for FINANCIAL FREEDOM

Adrian Stamer
Pro Member
Posted
  • Real Estate Investor & Agent
  • Richmond, VA
  • Posts 319
  • Votes 167
Originally posted by @Jay Hinrichs:
Originally posted by @Adrian Stamer:

I’d say about $20k monthly net after tax cash flows from real estate investments, but since these would be leveraged some still to optimize returns I would be looking at most likely $40k+ net profit from real estate. But I’m not one to rely on one source of income and require diversification so then there would be a required large bundle in index funds... prob still some semi active small business earnings to have a third income/wealth stream. High risk, high returns shoot the moon type of business but not required to succeed. I just enjoy starting new business projects 

But as someone who has been more or less self employed their entire life, let’s face it, been financially free for a long time. My idea of sitting still is sitting on a beach or mountain or bar somewhere exotic, then picking up my backpack and off to the next destination. With phone and laptop of course... but just in case. I take extra enjoyment writing real estate contracts on a beach somewhere in the Mediterranean 

 or the reverse I was on a cruise off o Italy in fall of 08 watching the BBC feed on the economic melt down our country suffered.. 

I wondered what I would have to come back to.. and well it was not pretty  LOL..  

 Okay so write that offer withdrawal somewhere on the Mediterranean and hope I was quick enough lol

Post: Rental 50%-Rule vs 30%-Rule on a SFH

Adrian Stamer
Pro Member
Posted
  • Real Estate Investor & Agent
  • Richmond, VA
  • Posts 319
  • Votes 167
Originally posted by @Joe Villeneuve:
Originally posted by @Adrian Stamer:
Originally posted by @Eric Gamble:

@Joe Villeneuve it seems you are operating in an environment I am moving towards.  When I worked in corporate America I did a great deal of reverse engineering.

@Adrian Stamer I am not attempt to "rock the Rule boat." I understand the rules are for "quick looks." However, with my limited experience, it seems that this rule might be making my thumb "too big" when analyzing SFH where the tenant will more than likely pay for all utilities.

 I agree, once you analyze enough properties you’ll be able to glance at the numbers and short cut mentally even further. I use rent to price ratios a lot more to filter through deals but I also pay attention to the propert type and class when looking at these numbers and adjust a little each way as needed 

I never use rent/price ratios because that ratio doesn't consider taxes, insurance, and a number of other things that are different, and have nothing to do with any ratio.

If you analyze markets, using specific criteria that groups properties without using "fudge factors", the market values define themselves.

 I’m typically operating in a specific geographical location so taxes are always with in a range that is completely corolatted with price. The other numbers are generally within ranges but anyway...

The point I was making when he was saying 30% or 50% rule was you do this to filter through results and then when you find the potentials you actually spreadsheet the numbers and see exactly where they come out. I buy a decent amount of fresh to the market in demand properties so I need to know how much I can offer to beat out competing offers

Post: Rental 50%-Rule vs 30%-Rule on a SFH

Adrian Stamer
Pro Member
Posted
  • Real Estate Investor & Agent
  • Richmond, VA
  • Posts 319
  • Votes 167
Originally posted by @Eric Gamble:

@Joe Villeneuve it seems you are operating in an environment I am moving towards.  When I worked in corporate America I did a great deal of reverse engineering.

@Adrian Stamer I am not attempt to "rock the Rule boat." I understand the rules are for "quick looks." However, with my limited experience, it seems that this rule might be making my thumb "too big" when analyzing SFH where the tenant will more than likely pay for all utilities.

 I agree, once you analyze enough properties you’ll be able to glance at the numbers and short cut mentally even further. I use rent to price ratios a lot more to filter through deals but I also pay attention to the propert type and class when looking at these numbers and adjust a little each way as needed