Is it me or are you guys getting crazy landlord policy quotes?

[Matt M.]

Hey guys,

I am closing on the other half of a twin/double I already own and am calling around for landlord policy quotes. The quotes I am getting seem quite high, and vary differently. Different replacement costs, premiums, etc. these houses are mirror images of themselves, and major systems updated around the same time.

what gives? And are there any big companies out there that you guys are pleased with?