Going with A. 1.Window in the kitchen.

Quote from @Hazel Anderson: Hello, bigger pockets pros, We have a rental property in Columbus and we are looking for a contractor who can replace the existing basement window with a standard sized window.

Renovations were mostly cosmetic but included a new roof, windows, siding, front and back porch and patio, new flooring, paint, kitchen, bathrooms, fixtures.

All of the doors and windows are new.

And now, how much more will a buyer pay now that the kitchen is bigger.

Needs gutters, full kitchen and bath, floors, paint with some drywall repair, windows, front porch and the deck on the rear is pretty poor as well.

In Indianapolis C to B class neighborhoods I have rarely seen insulation upgraded on rentals especially doubles that have never been owner-occupied.  4th air gaps,  poorly fitting windows, and doors can be easily corrected with proper caulk and weatherstripping (usually).

Hey Peter,Unfortunately, a window can't be added to the basement.

Quote from @Devin James: We’ve slowly been improving our homes the more we’ve built and the more feedback we get from our Buyers2021 – Added 8ft doors throughout the home2022 – Added a new elevation with stone in the front of the home2023 – NO carpet in the bedrooms, LVP throughout the home2024 – Added hurricane impact windows & new color options2025 – Adding Ceiling FansGotta be open to feedback and adjust accordinglyThis can be the difference of your home sitting on the market for 4 months vs 1 month where's the modifications and pictures?

I would do it even if I sell far outside the 18 month window.