What is your biggest struggle? 

Regarding insurance adding additional umbrella insurance is great idea. 

The biggest issue was getting it out of there. $250.

Do any of the tenants have Dogs (Breed restrictions are individual to each company).These may not prevent you from getting insurance but they may limit the number of companies willing to insure it.

Erin,Were you able to find insurance? 

Unless there is an emergency situation, take a lot of photos and call your insurance agent before doing any repairs.

Usually when I close on a house, the insurance company sends out somebody to do a visual inspection.

Quote from @Marc Zak: Anyone have experience on the issue of getting insurance on a property held in an LLC?

SIGNED STATEMENT OF INSURED AS REQUIRED BY SECTION 3905.33 OF THE OHIOREVISED CODEThe named insured ___________, acknowledges that the insurance policy (other than life insurance) as described above is to be placed with an insurance company not authorized to do business in Ohio.The insured understands that the insurance company is not a member of the Ohio Insurance Guaranty Association and that Chapter 3955. of the Ohio Revised Code is not applicable to claimants or insureds of said insurance company.

We don't rely on insurance, they love to deny.