If you are inclined to give him $200, that's your prerogative.

I'm inclined to not rent this unit to her, but not sure what my legal responsibilities are.

I am inclined to agree with the RE agent.

That link IMO is not relevant to your situation as it's in Florida and she is an agent as well as an idiot.I'd get on the phone and head this off at the pass, the longer it hangs in question the more inclined they may be to investigate, as time passes memories fade, recall is less reliable and investigation can justify action, you want to avoid that, you don't even want to meet with investigators!

The Mortgagee will not be inclined to take a short pay if the borrower was paid (by you for the Sub2) and if you wait too long to inquire for the principal reduction you will likely have issues with borrower participation.Notate as well, the Borrower who seeks principal reduction may be required by the Mortgagee to affirm they will reside in the property for another set of years.

Makes sense and that would be my inclination for how to treat them when/if I owned a portfolio.

As we get further into a mortgage, particularly once you reach the tipping point where the principal portion of the mortgage payment is larger than the interest component, we are less inclined to make prepayments.  

(Not that I am inclined to do so unless it's in the context of the the 0% capital gains tax scenario that K.

You will find a couple of pockets in town where property values are on a heavy incline while taxes remain low.

I am inclined to charge a nominal for additional rent to add a party but if they push back, you may have to let it go.Screening new party is non-negotiable.If you want to keep them, this might be a good chance to get them to sign for another year and just let the bad apple out.