There’s tax consequences for the partner who is exiting as well as basis issues the accountant should weigh in on. 

There are some who believe all plumbing should be done by licensed plumbers and using unlicensed person for plumbing has risks that are unwarranted.The issue as I see it is useful life of faucet likely means replacement cost should have been prorated.  

Hello,I'm looking for toilet recommendations to use in a rental house.Since I'm responsible for paying for the water, I would like something with a low water usage that still gets the job done effectively, and has as few issues as possible.What brand/model would you guys recommend?

It seems your issue is two fold, partially due to poor underlayment/uneven floor and thickness of the LVP can play into that too.

You can always reecaluate in 2-3 years before the capital gains issue kicks in, but all signs are that homes in Denver will be go up in value between now and when you really need to make a decision. 

From my experience so far, Airbnb never failed to cover any issues I had caused by guests. 

You are a knowledgeable investor and even you believed that link was on point BUT it is NOT AT ALL!

Even during Covid finding 2 sets of washers and dryers, and 26 sets of pre-cut blinds for an 80 year old house was not an issue.

That's a starter home in 2024... you would have no issues selling.

Work with your accountant to do so just in case there's any issues remaining in that LLC.