One side vacant is the best time to sell.

DIY online cost segs that are <$1k are being tossed out in audit like yesterday's garbage lately. 

I would recommend that regardless of market you decide to invest in that you find a fellow investor/realtor that can help you purchase in the neighborhoods that make for ideal long term rentals.

I think this is most valuable because there is a lot of discussion surrounding owning investment property in an LLC or not, and this insurance topic rarely comes up in the discussion.

But, then you still have your Indiana LLCs and Indiana is a much more business-friendly state.You would have to be in one heck of a lawsuit for someone to want to try to break through both.

Maybe selling is the best option stop the bleeding and do something that is more risk adverse. 

Thanks in advance for any advice!

@Giovanni BarbosaIt’s great that you're starting in real estate!

But, for future reference, in Ohio there is a little used approach to always get your money back.

These are professionals with additional training and a stricter code of ethics.