They have a HELOC of ~$60kNumbers:Comps suggest ~$199.5/sqft (max 2,020 sqft)Estimated ARV: $335k (based on comps)Potential rent: $1,975-$2,000/monthQuestion: Do these numbers seem reasonable for the Braselton market?

Cleveland is a great rental market, with a low cost of entry and strong rents. 

We are real-estate investors from CA & trying to pick an OOS market with Tulsa (stable economy and future outlook, modest appreciation & reasonable cash-flow).We heard from family/friends about new construction duplexes around the Tulsa metro targeting investors. 

Purchase price: $176,000 Cash invested: $80,000 Off-Market Deal in Southern Orchards that was found through cold-calling.

There is no secret sauce to getting/finding properties other than what is already told out there in the real estate market - 50% bootstrapping 50% luck - same as finding a great wholesale deal.

Hard money loans are a great option for off-market properties, but that is a whole other world that I may not suggest for someone just starting off unless you have some rock solid mentorship. 

Either go to local real estate oriented meet-ups or post in FB groups that are for real estate in different Colorado markets.

Both were off market deals. 

Hotel/Motel, Condo, Apartments all have had substantial rates because a lot of companies have either stopped writing the business or non-renewed it and the companies that will still write it have to take premium because of the risk they're taking on.I know that doesn't help you at all but my advice would be if you have an independent agent who you trust and like and believe they're doing the best they can for you stick with them and let them work all the markets for you.

These markets often offer better entry points and potential for appreciation.