If you want an island, delete the peninsula and instead of putting the fridge there, (like in your updated sketch) put the stove there.

I have a person like this in Pawleys Island, Myrtle Beach, Blue Ridge, Tybee Island, Hilton Head, Savannah, Panama City Beach, Gulf Shores, Bryson City and Outer Banks.

We've currently been looking to expand into Florida, Tennessee, or South Carolina to diversify a bit as our other rentals we used the BRRRR method for are located in Island Park, Idaho.

FAR more valuable than money  time@Jerryll Noorden Cold calling is a sport of consistency that WILL and ALWAYS leads to motivated sellers.

Long Island prices grew to the point deals no longer made sense.

I own a multi-family unit near Mid-Town  and had some challenges early on with tenants but in the last 2 years I have adjusted my process with each room being rented on average 8 months per person; along with only marginal changes for utilities and fixed internet and cable cost no matter how much they use those services.With rents rising at the pace they are now and consistent low inventory this will be more of an option for qualified renters in the future. 

Quite a beautiful island to call home. 

Either find the deals yourself, or connect with someone who has a consistent stream of deals and focus your energy deciphering which one you should jump on.If you are finding your own deals, drive around and find the best sub markets that have numerous BRRRR potential properties.

Getting the work done consistently is almost impossible unless you go through one of the larger property management companies.

Tough to find houses in my price range, but I'm looking consistently!