How much exposure do I have?

Up to you on how big of a deal that exposure is.

I want this to have as much exposure as possible.  

Recently, we created the first (as far as we are aware) residential assisted living focused fund and have successfully raised for multiple homes, giving our investors and us exposure to the cash flow, and equity upside that comes from owning the real estate and the business.

Maybe your situation is different and if you don’t feel comfortable in the neighborhood then this may be a moot point anyway.As for FHA, my understanding is that you must intend to live in the house for a year  it sounds like you did intend to, but due to unexpected circumstances- lead exposure and unexpected unsafe neighborhood- you have to move.

Ironically its the investors in the layered LLC's who believe they are hidden in the cloaks of secrecy and better protected who end up in  the most costly and drawn out litigation while giving the plaintiff attorneys reason to take a more thorough look under the hood.Keep your LLC ownership simple, carry appropriate insurance, make sure ever vendor you work with carries appropriate insurance and those who perform work functions most likely to lead to liability exposure list you ad additional insured (not merely certificate holder) and it should go without saying, avoid negligent conduct.

An annuity is definitely a different level of risk exposure than this type of an alternative investment. 

I listed a rental property on Zillow and paid for premium exposure to increase visibility.

I can't comment on the Indianapolis market but I am always weary of individuals jumping into flipping houses as their first exposure to real estate.

In my limited exposure to using PMs in Memphis (I self-manage), most had a scale of upcharge depending on the cost of the service.