Fortunately, we weren't fooled and we lost no money, but it wasted a ton of time and faith in humanity.

You can need to reach out to the County of Passaic's Department of Human Services. 

1) Human nature is that the majority of people that will take the time to post are those that are angry.

How will an eviction affect a tenant.Donot put any thoughts of human factor/feelings here.Plz comment as you are in my shoes and you running it as a business Scenario: Had a flip project ,did 85k worth of rehab ,put on market in March of 2020,PANDEMIC CAME and we freak out .Listed for sale + For lease.Potential tenant came in saying they are moving from another state,Wife lost work due to pandemic layoff ,Husband has offer letter here in TX for 80k offer.They were selling their house and brining in 100k + want to buy house after 1 yr of lease (POTENTIAL TENANTS WHY Should YOU CONSIDER US LETTER) ,Good credit score ,No red flags on Credit report.

@Tyler SpeelmanAppraisers are human too, they make mistakes. 

Health first of body & mind.

Remember the word is INVESTOR, that's all about leverage, so use human leverage, like every great investor does. 

Heartbreaking that three able bodied adults are guilting you into letting them freeload. 

We are all humans and appraisers make mistakes too.

In the meantime, any body know of some RE clubs in the Woodbridge/DMV area?