I then would spend more money to get the house ready to rent and look into the business side/league aspects of renting a home.Positives - Long-term financial benefit; I would assume that I can get roughly $900 a month renting this home - after taxes and insurance it would be safe to say I would profit $725.

One of their clients who came over called them "Bush League" and I found it kind of funny.

These sellers seemed out of their league. 

The other markets that I was considering before I made a decision were League City TX (10%), Pearland Tx (11%), Texas City TX (8%), Norman OK (12%) all have  a price to rent ratio that is lower than Winter Garden.

In baseball terminology, I would call this a homerun single.

As turnkey as possible with opportunity for organic improvements and revenue growth as units turn over but I'd prefer to stay away from a major league rehab at this point. 

In baseball, good trading partners are made when both sides win.

They want to see the portfolio cash flows.The market has changed a bit and your portfolio puts you in the big leagues compared to the normal part time or full time RE investor (most have fewer than 10 properties).

League City was all the rage and Dickinson had never been heard of. 

He stuck a camera into the vent pipe and...Yes, that's a baseball.