@Michael PlaksSorry if I wasn’t clear.

I interpretttev @Alan Asriants statement different than you but agree it is not clear   He could be indicating pools, basements, sunrooms do not provide a means for an extra tenant.  

Just looking at Zillow I’m having a hard time making the numbers work between prop taxes, insurance, management on 20% Down vs cash currently earning 5% (albeit that 5% going away soon with rate cuts)  To be completely honest, there's not much right now that will give you decent cashflow without getting into a full rehab.

If you do this, make sure you have clear intentions and written terms each party agrees to.  

It’s better to cut your losses now.Hate the process of finding new tenants?

It cost him a few hundred bucks, but she was happy, and more importantly, he didn’t have to deal with an expensive lawsuit or bad online reviews.Here’s what I’d recomend doing:Check Your Legal Standing: Since the fence isn’t in her lease and not part of the surveyed property, you’re probably in the clear to remove it.

Clearly an opportunity to invest in a more landlord friendly state than NY.

Clear communication on expectations is key—I'd definitely push them to split that $250 cost at the very least! 

As GPs, we owe it to our partners and stakeholders to keep communication clear, honest, and consistent.

The typical income from a free and clear rental would probably be $800-1500/month - and on a financed rental probably $300/month on a good day in today’s market.