We own the listing and self manage.

Does anyone know of a dscr lender that will allow for seasoned money for a down payment and a really good property manager in Ohio specifically in Columbus, Cin, and Cleveland?  

Management treats line employees quite poorly and lying is just part of the job.

A lot to unpack here, though, to really decide.

They liked my offer and the rapport I built with them and decided they wanted to sell to me even though another offer was higher.

I think it's more about the people honestly - if I decide that I'm going that route than I'd narrow it down to 4 or 5 cities and I'd try to meet some agents and property management companies from there. 

Owner will need an Annual Owner Statement from your acconting system, reflecting those gross collected amounts and all expenses, including your management fees.

The ability to effectively self manage would depend on the scale you are trying to buy. 

We haven't yet decided what to do with the railing, but I know this isn't what I want!

What is your average rent amount for all properties managed?