Some high-end STR's (like in Joshua Tree) do use professional models, but for your market and property type, I’d suggest removing personal photos and focusing on the space itself, so guests can imagine themselves there, which is really what you want.You also have 81 photos, that’s too many.

If you are in a state where eviction cost is high and it is tenant friendly you may need a higher credit score to offset default risk and eviction cost.If you are in a landlord friendly state where it is easier to get non paying tenants out you may be able to handle more none payment risk.  

I have an outdoor pool that easily have 1k+ people using it every season and I never had single complaint due to the water quality.

The market in Racine is much different than Kenosha and we have been having a hard time getting quality tenant applicants.

they won't pay super high in that area according to my experience. 2bed is paying 650 to 750 let me know if you manage to get higher than that.

You can go to Redfin or Zillow and see the level of finish houses with short DOM have in the area, can you at least match that quality?

This is a straightforward process that we’ve followed to consistently deliver high-performance properties, and it does not require secrets or gurus.

The two are almost entirely different markets in terms of price points, returns, tenant quality, and overall investing strategy.

From the sentiment of your post it seems like you're viewing the buyers as strictly investors when they may lean more towards traditional homeowners looking for a quality of life improvement or an improvement on their current financial situation today.Let's say the buyer pays 465k and has a 5% interest rate.

Try to screen for a higher quality tenant next time.