OTOH if there are screaming deals where builders are losing their shirt to unload a similiar property then absolutely not.

Woke up from working at it the next morning and heard TV in the next room and went in and saw where the first plane hit the building.Then while they were discussing that I saw LIVE on tv the second plane hit and it was crazy.Then you saw people running through the smoke on the street screaming from the fallout of the buildings collapsing.I remember later that year driving to a pizza convention from Georgia to New Jersey and I saw the pentagon damage from the road.Look liked something out of a movie set as it didn't seem real seeing it from the road.All we can do is keep living.Some things are just hard to comprehend or understand as to why they happen.

Starting to wonder if I should run away screaming...

It might take a visit or two for them to feel comfortable. 

A lot of people scream its illegal, many people say it’s against the law and you are acting like a unlicensed broker or unlicensed agent.I get it.

Make sure your lease has joint and several liability and clauses that limit number of days a visitor can stay in a row so you can avoid ending up with a rogue tenant you haven't vetted in your property.

The yield alone screams that there is risk in the transaction.  

Let's say you find a screaming deal which is turnkey, fully rented and is worth $300K. 

What is your conversion rate, or, said differently, what percentage of visitors fill out your form?

Every investor I know is screaming they can't find any deals.