I would ask the insurance company for more documentation on the reasoning. 

You can try Rhino or Qira, but these are ventured back companies. 

You may want to first explore cities that you are already familiar with.Think of cities where you grew up, went to school, like to vacation to or see family.You will have a better idea of what the good / bad parts of town than a brand new city that you are unfamiliar with.Best of luck.

I've had 14 SF rentals in 6 different states, using 6 different management companies. 

I assume a higher upfront cost as far as land purchase and the actual build but you would have a brand new house, instant equity and hopefully maintenance free for quite a while.

My managment company has made more than a reasonable amount of attempts to get the HOA to have this repaired. 

Now we are in 2025 and although I still own the trucking company, it has been an inconsistent pit that has technically brought me personally no profit.

This could be a reputation and brand killer.  

Is there some reason that you or the company simply don't discuss what happened and use this as an opportunity to turn a negative post into a positive one for the company?  

For example, the insurance company offers you $100k.