I’m thinking about selling it but wanted to hear your perspective, especially since the interest rate is so low at 4.75% & I don’t necessarily like the idea of selling an investment property but know my money could potentially be better elsewhere.

Quote from @Richard Bautista: Good evening,Just saw Cleveland, Ohio has relatively inexpensive houses which has the potential to cashflow.

If there is not enough STRs in the market you are in then you have to adjust business practices.

Here you would have to put it in the MLS if your are with NAR, but it wouldn't syndicate out to all of the public sights, and you can send it to any potential buyer that you may know.

Quote from @Christian Styles: Potentially able to help you find someone but I would need to know specifically where the property is in order to know who to recommend.  

And my goal of trying it out would just to get familiar so I could potentially buy in a much better market. 

Your property definitely has the potential to benefit from a cost segregation study.

They also have a pay-as-you-go setup, so you’re not stuck in a subscription—just a simple, practical option for better skip tracing.If you haven't already I would consider giving Prime Tracers a shot.

It's deceptive practice, plain n simple. 

A ring camera will give you the evidence you need to stop a potential party or when people bring in too many guests over night.