I wound up just turning it into the police.

I wound up installing the unit on the roof instead.

It had two Honeywell round thermostats at different settings (inside one of those clear plastic vented boxes), and a spring-wound timer switch that ran for an hour or two (easily accessible).

I wound up switching everything to Landlordlocks.

You do not indicate how much over half rent they want to charge but you wound be having 2 BRs of 4 BRs with the other 2 empty a majority of the time.  

I've served 26 Months in Iraq attached to a Recon Unit and Have earned the Combat Medical Badge for rendering aid under fire, and the Purple Heart for wounds recieved in action.

Since you have no historical taxable basis to write off against that sale price, you may find yourself having to pay taxes on the full sales price, not just your profits.Happily, there is a way to heal these self inflicted wounds.  

Then I wound up leaving my job after just 4 years. 

In fact, I avoid it as they charge like wounded bulls.And as someone else already said on this thread I think; DISCLOSE, DISCLOSE, DISCLOSE!

I wound up getting a direct supervisor to respond at the company they worked for as they put them down as a personal reference.