Maybe you could document how to take them to small claims (and increase your odds of winning) and then seo it so they end up with bunch of tiny cases all over the country.But honestly this doesn't sound like the best use of your time unless you have extra and just want to make a point.

I'm just going to tell you though, getting property SEO (search engine optimization) and a website that can handle all the ins and outs takes a lot of work, time and energy. 

Do you have a website for SEO?

I learned SEO, while I did Direct mail marketing.

It helps build SEO that lasts, increases sharing and boosts inbound traffic via third party links.

Direct Mail, Facebook and Google ads, SEO, RVM, Text messages, door knocking, Cold Calling etc.

What I'm wondering is, should I hire someone to help me with SEO on my current site or start over with a company like lead propeller.   

If you are doing websites, then SEO and credibility is a challenge.

With "good" leads getting more and more scarce, where do you find most of your leads (cold calling, direct mail, driving for dollars, SEO, PPC)?

I've had a great section tenant for 5 years with very few issues, super clean, and I will be able to turn over the property effortlessly.