@Elvon Bowman Do you have an example of the ideal property or a price point?

Quote from @Miguel Del Mazo: Knowing more about the area, it sounds like you'll have an ideal avatar of wealthy, young and trendy professionals that aren't ready for or looking for a home to own.

That is less than ideal in some ways as well. 5.

As for your scenario, how many bedrooms would be ideal?

Yes, looking for another property now, ideally one where I don't have to live in a closet

Ideally the owner would handle everything and would have no need for a property management company with only this single duplex in their portfolio. 

In playing with the numbers a bit, I'm seeing a trend of atleast 2% rent to price and (ideally) < 7% mortgage rate needed to achieve a decent cash on cash rate.

Ideally, no more than 5% over median and no lower than 15% under median.

Zillow is not ideal because this is a monthly furnished rental - which Zillow doesn't have a specific platform for - but that's what has worked for me up to now. 

If there's equity maybe selling and restarting would be ideal unless you can up income/cut down expenses