Originally posted by @Rich S.:
The bottom line is develop your criteria and stick to them. If you are comfortable at $100K because it meets your cash flow percentage or amount, offer that. The time you spend trying for the perfect offer is time wasted not working on your business, evaluating other properties, etc. The other thing I would say is get creative, say $100K, but offer expires in 2 hours. It may or may not work, but it also might get them to feel like they need to decide or counter. If you are willing to pay $100K after negotiating back and forth, you might as well just offer it straight away and be done, either way.
Myself, and my clients spend a matter of 10 seconds to formulate our offer, once the numbers are ran and now we know its us and 2 others. So it's not so much a matter of spending the time to formulate what the offer is going to be, the question is what type of buyer are you. As the thread has proven, there is way more than one way to skin a cat.
I like your creativeness, and that can work with certain sellers, but if you have ever dealt with REO than you know they would laugh at that, of just flat out tell you they won't be responding for 2-3 days. Iv mentioned it a few times now, and maybe I should have maybe made that a stipulation in the OP, the goal was to make price the only variable. Of course all sellers are going to be different and have different needs. So I was trying to draw out what type of buyer you are, not how many different ways can we try to gain leverage in a way other than price. I appreciate the input though, and I do think its a great approach, but it also doesn't work in all situations.
Also, there is no negotiating., no feeling the seller out. Its a one and done offer. You are up against 2 other offers, they either take yours or one of theirs. I know this is not a real life situation, again just trying to see how people approach the "value" of getting a deal done, compared to the "value" a few thousand dollars financed over 30 years.