@Mike Lambert
Great info! Thanks for your response.
I can see I need to clarify! I am buying the home in pesos, but converted it for here, so people could understand. It's also not a money play. We are renting it out for the next year or two simply to have someone there and to earn a little bit of money. We had no intention of it needing to follow any rules at all! I put this out there to give a little info to people about buying property in Mexico. I am no expert! I just love Mexico, and hope to share about that. I never see anything about inland Mexico, and especially not Oaxaca. This purchase is going to be my home, and I will also be making a little money off of the STR.
The city center here in Oaxaca is ridiculously overpriced, in my opinion. It's hard to find properties in the city with a nice patio and STR potential for less than around 5 million that are reasonably habitable. We have seen some real losers for loads of money. We scored this one for 3.8 million because it's not in the exact centro historico. I do think it's pricey, but we love it and will be happy there. We can walk to Santo Domingo from our house in 15 minutes and it has a green area in front where we can plant and have a garden. This is hard to find in the city! We plan on making the home as "green" as possible and having an organic garden and fruit trees in front.
I have absolutely no interest in investing on the coast. I spent a lot of time in Tulum and Playa del Carmen in my youth (I'm an old timer!). I backpacked all over Mexico "back in the day". The last time I went to the coast I literally cried at what I saw. Even little Puerto E is getting to the point of being depressing, but I get that things change. It's just the environmental destruction is hard to stomach. It's better for my mental health to remember it the way it was and find new places to play.
My parents and I used to own a condo in Cantamar, Baja about 35 years ago, way before the fideicomiso system. My family used it for many happy years. We sold it around 2004 after the kids and grandkids were grown and my parents were too old to use it. There were no problems with the sale, and I would say we broke even with inflation.
As far as my house, I didn't have enough cash to pay for it, so I had to convince the owner to carry it for me. She was asking 4.2 million, so I offered the 3.8 with the owner carry for the three years. It was just to buy the property. I couldn't have done it otherwise! I don't plan on selling anytime soon, but I expect with the upgrades the home will hold it's value or increase its value a little bit over time. We will retire there next year or the year after.
Living here in Oaxaca will solve some of our retirement issues since the house will be paid for, and our medical expenses will be very low here. Our living expenses are also super low here, so we can afford a lifestyle here that we couldn't in the states. We love to travel, so we need extra money for our travel "bug" affliction. So, we think it's a good money move for us to have a free and clear home to live in, with a small income from the STR and with virtually zero tax costs. But definitely not a great pure money investment!
Way different goals than you have, but I thought might be worth sharing.
PS Our latest travel blog is at https://gtherewego.com/