@Jay Hinrichs - Going eyeball to eyeball with your CPA? I guess you've never heard the following joke. In a circle of accountants talking, how do you pick out the out going one? It's the one who compliments the others shoes. :-)
You are a slightly different bird than most investors. When you get into more continual transactions and more advanced planning sessions with that requested adviser, a face to face, golf, lunch type relationship might be what someone is needing. Although, you can still get those same required touches, conversation and social aspects if planned well with a virtual CPA. While I don't necessarily see some of my far flung clients every year, when they come to St. Louis or when I'm in their neck of the woods I make it a point to visit and catch up.
With that being said, most real estate investors don't need that many planned touches. I welcome a client who wants a planned schedule and more touches. The more I meet with someone, the better advice and planning we can do which makes my service more valuable to my client. Most real estate investors need access. The access to ask their CPA specific questions regarding their situation, planning and potential acquisitions/disposals. The access that they know they can get a quick, educated answer that can be explained to them in a way that they understand. They need access to someone they trust and have built even a slight relationship with so that they know they can reach out and have someone in their corner.
I would never recommend an investor use turbo tax. You might be fully capable of getting your best return done on your own, why would you hope that's the case when you can hire a professional? Even if you have done it right the first year, was there any planning done for years 2, 3,4, etc? After having done some rehab work myself, I know that you let the painters paint, the drywallers drywall and the accountants account.
@Grady L. - You won't need a state specific CPA. While state tax laws can vary and there are some planning aspects to implementing a plan in each state, the majority of your planning will be done to the IRS Code and not the the state tax laws. Any state nuances can be researched by your CPA.