@Aaron K. thx for the reply. I should clarify that I didn't mean to suggest long term gains are't important or worth considering. The goal, however, is to have best CoC Returns in passive income, while the long term gains of appreciation in say 10-15 years, are more of a given. Even though having someone pay your mortgage is great, the short term goal is not just to break even, but to provide highest possible monthly return as well, while those appreciations take place. These "short-term" gains also provide a buffer towards long term sustainability. For example, if I can get 3x more than my mortgage in rent (at fair market value), then I also have more cushion to lower rents and absorb vacancies during downturns, thus ensuring I can keep my properties and long term gains.
Curious, the locations you mentioned ...did others share any numbers to support? I, for example, own properties in Pueblo, CO. Currently get between 10-14% CoC Return (including CapEx) for properties under 200k mark. Highly doubtful I hit the jackpot picking this location so wondering where else in the country can perform better.