After weighing the pros and cons and reading all the helpful advice on this forum. I think I'm going to sell. I'll try and 1031 exchange if I can manage to find something decent in this market, otherwise I may just wait for it to cool or look elsewhere for cap rate.
I have a contractor who's worked on the building in question and he made some good points. Cloth wiring, possible lead paint, cast iron plumbing. These could all lead to huge CapEx costs in the not so near future.
Also I didn't realize that if I were to take over the property the mortgage would have to be redone since it's currently held jointly with my brother. My realtor explained that I would have to start a new mortgage at current rates and pay the costs to process that. All in all it seems like it's probably for the best to just cash out and move on to something else.
Thanks for the solid advice @Dave Foster @Edwin Epperson and @Patricia Steiner