@Brandon Hall These rules will basically make it difficult for you to claim the net taxable loss (if any) caused by your self-rental.
>>> Im not concerned with creating or fabricating losses to reduce my liabilities, and I would certainly follow all the rules. I am curious if this efffects the depreciation value though. If that is what technically makes you have a loss, is that not considered? Or would certain things be considered separately? Like depreciation? would it be allowed? Interest on mortgage?
@Russell Brazil You will miss out on the greatest tax break available to the american public, the $500,000 exemption from capital gains on a primary residence sale.
>>> What if the plan is to hold for 30+ years? And then if I do buy it personally at first, and want to turn it into an investment property to get it out of my name, what does that look like? And how do I avoid the potential taxes?
@Joe Splitrock
@Joe Splitrock If this was allowed, everyone would just rent their house back to themselves at a loss. We could take all repairs, lawn care, utilities and insurance as an expense. The problem is you cannot claim expenses from your personal residence as a tax write off. You cannot take a loss on your primary residence through depreciation.
>>> So even if it was structured, run, and documented like a legitimate business model as if I was renting to any old John Smith out there, I couldnt make any of these deductions and it would still be considered as my primary residence and disregarded as a business holding. Even though it has current history for 5+ years as being a rental property, and it would be held under my rental company next, with intentions of it being such a property, with me being the tenant for the first 1-3 years of ownership, it would not be regarded as such?
You are the first person I have heard with this great idea, which leads me to believe it is not as good as you think.
>>> Bit harsh, dont ya think? Im six months into this and trying to figure out best practices and strategy, so I dont know that its kookie, and I certainly dont think it ever hurts to ask questions and learn why it is, or may not be, the best practice.
And I certainly hope you dont believe that just because YOU personally havent experienced something first hand that it makes it invalid or somehow less deserving of discussion.